>>268298978There was already a thread but fuck it may as well use this one and leave the sales talk to the existing one
Kagurabachi won and only ESLs disagree
Is Bucket actually gonna get U19'd?
>>268299107>ESL post>Can't even write proper english
Who the fuck is Makoto Yukimura? Literally who rec KGB.
>Tachidesk doesn't work>Hakuneko doesn't work>mloader doesn't workDays like this I really wish I could take every single nerd and just slap them until they manage to make some shit that actually work without needing to manually fix it.
chapters out
>>268299208Vinland Saga, retardbro.
>>268299279Hakuneko still works if you rip from the viz website instead
YOKAI BUSTERS DOES IT AGAIN
>>268299196>ESL got caught again claiming a mistake when there is none
>>268299416Nah, I'm outside the US.
Kagurabachi>>268299375Ruri Dragon>>268299388Nue's Exorcist>>268299280Astro Royale>>268299320Blue Box>>268299474
How Psych House becomed so boring in few chapters?.
>>268299685thanks
>>268298978You guys think kagurabachi's fight-ending revolves too much around "teleports behind you"?
>>268299753oh lookbattle shounen toddlers honeymoon with bucket already over just like their experience with all SoL manga.who could have guessed...
>>268299753Ikr. Either introduce a new character or do something with the “plot”
>>268298978Thank you for the non-shill thread
Are we trending kbgtards
>>268299679>>268299064
>>268299208>Yo, the print was so low cause they bought someone big's obi. Must be Kishimoto.>Its literally who.>Uhhh, actually Vinland Saga author is great!>'Vilnland Saga shat the bed early on, turning into pacifict bullshit'.Uh oh.
I just saw the title for this weeks ruri and it got me pretty excited this better deliever
>>268299753too many chapters in a row that didn't introduce any new elements. No new characters, no new running gags, no plot developments, no indication of any long term goals, etc. Basically it's felt aimless even by SoL standards, like Ruri has also kinda felt like it's been in a rut lately but at least the boring drama with the one girl and the school council shit was SOMETHING. Literally nothing has happened in Bucket for almost a month now.
>>268299208>literal retard
Super Psychic Policeman Chojo>>268299958Elusive Samurai>>268299583
>>268299951Welp I was disappointed>>268299947Vinland saga was always pacifist, but still there was definitely a change in the authors attitudes that made him go full retard
>>268299852Knew it would happen. It's so transparent they don't actually read sol.
Oh well, Kiyoshi is Mashle ver.1.5.
>>268299685fuck you
>>268300823???
Do you guys read Jump in a particular order? I just read my least interested series first and end with my favorite.
>>268299208>check xitter>nothingso are we just making up recommendations now
>>268300707Yep, when he said he had already graduated I hoped for no school shenanigans, but here we are.And his gimmick is gone so now he's just super strong and a bit awkward.
WOAHHHHHH KUBO REC?????????????
>>268300823You put KGB in the same post as those peasants manga, FUCK you
>>268300707I really expected the second fight to be at least a little easierhow many demon lords did they say there were again, maybe it's meant to be super short
>>268300951Reverse of the order mangaplus puts them in, so the less popular stuff first
Kill Blue>>268300479Psych House>>268300988Kyokuto Necromance>>268301385Akane-Banashi>>268301369
>>268300438>Welp I was disappointedNext chapter it looks like, but also my cope is this chapter is foreshadowing it transitioning to semi-shonen battle kino where she actually uses her powers. Like a calm before the storm.
>>268300951My favorite then toc order.
>>268301560>Kill BlueHOLY KINO, KILL BLUE DID IT AGAIN!
>>268301593I don't even really want battles, I just want the fucking dragon powers to have some sort of relevance at all.
Maikeru did it!He didn't get Issho's blessing though.
>>268301824Issho still allowed everyone else to vote.That's an improvement, he just has impossibly high standards.
>>268301674nice
>>268301824Wifekane foreshadowing KGB next week chapter.
>>268301706Well, what relevance would they have in the boring modern world? The only useful one I could think of is flight, which she hasn't gotten. The characters even say so themselves, the powers aren't really relevant in the boring modern world.
>>268302049Maybe it should have just been a short series about her learning to deal with each new power
>>268299904Thank you for telling me I wasn't a complete retard for using similar method
Nue was KINO again this chapter
>>268301447It's not like he has to actually fight a Demon Lord every chapter, or that they're all equally weak. It's just a repeat gag for now.
>>268302328I swear this guy doesn't understand how to use blacks.
>>268299428Good Chapter this week, I like the new girl they added, plus it's an added dimension for roasting.
>>268301447*at least a little harder
Nope, not reading Kagurabachi.
>>268302525I understand what he's going for with it, it's clearly trying to do it similar to Kubo's work in Bleach but I don't think he shades it quite how he's hoping to. Looks fine otherwise but it's just not quite hitting what he's striking for yet.
>>268301824
>>268302328Yeah it was pretty good for Nue standards. Ready to be done with this fight though.
Goatchads won this week.
>>268302561Yeah great addition
>>268303070>aquatic theme>suddenly a goatHuh?
>roboco isn't kin-
Another KINO chapter of SaKINOto Days, the proud father of KINO Blue.
>>268303070>>268303197capricornshub-niggurath
>pulling uu numbersIt's over
>>268303197Goat was in Chapter 3.
>>268303708It's a friend?
>>268303765Sure. Just look at him. He's practically smiling.
Hot A.I girl blows DILF's mind!
Ultimate Exorcist Kiyoshi>>268303175
Undead Unluck>>268302698
>>268299753The plot has stagnated. I dropped it it now with this chapter. I liked it at the start.
>>268304302i don't think we can fix her bros
>>268300691I read SoL
Why us no one making saka dumpy threads
>>268304302DEEP RAPUTA IS SO GOOD
Why us no one making roboco dumpy threads
Why us no one making murakami dumpy threads
uhm, author comment doko?
author comments onegai?
GIGA
What killed the wsj threads?
https://mangaplus.shueisha.co.jp/web_pages/1504/
>>268305234The nue v kgb schizoposter
>>268305276>It may have seemed that Endeavor’s arm grew back in the last chapter, but just assume that was your eyes playing tricks on you.WEAK
MID is trending
>>268298978WSJ Issue #30 TOCExorcist no Kiyoshi-kun (Cover, Lead CP, New Series)1 - Sakamoto Days2 - One PieceYoukai Buster Murakami (CP)3 - Akane Banashi4 - Mission: Yozakura FamilyBlue Box (CP)5 - Witch Watch6 - Me & RobocoKagura Bachi (CP)7 - Astro Royale8 - Super Psychic Policeman ChojoHana no Kimi (One-Shot)NEW - Psych House9 - Nue's Exorcist10 - The Elusive Samurai11 - Undead Unluck12 - Kill Blue13 - Kyokuto Necromance
>>268298978Does anyone remember the title of the one shot with the girl with a big ass sword and a wolf? I think it was by one of Hori's assistants. I would kill to see if getting serialized
>>268299753I think its actually a matter of the paneling being too dull. Lots of better SoL might have little going on but more dynamic paneling so it still feels like something is happening.
>>268305828So is the Necromance mangaka just cursed? Both this and Alines went straight to the bottom, right?
It's impossible to any WSJ series to trend in the top 30 today, Kimetsu literally take all the slot lol
>>268303325ngl I was really hoping the plotline set up with Kaoru would continue instead
>>268306096It will never not fascinate me how such a milquetoast cookiecutter series got this level of popularity.
>>268306096Last episode was so fucking good too, at times like this the anime really pulls no stops.The rest of the season was meh and stretched a short arc a lot, but damn this last episode delivered.Wish it went on just to see Douma eating Shinobu.
>>268306185honestly I thought kny was more generic and boring then BC.
Kawaguchi pls.......release the series already.....
>>268306499Gorillachads WILL win.
>>268304886our dumper started working sundays
I'm getting Hajimete no Hitozuma vibes from this...
>>268305276>no one dying this timewhat the fuck?
KEK
>>268306855its over, should have made an exorcist JK feMC then forget all about her powers and focus on school SoL
>>268306855Necrophiles, these cushions are so damn comfy
>>268306855You'd think Japan would like kiyoshi.Maybe should have released during mashle s2.
>>268306855I thought nips really like Kiyoshi I like it too...
>>268307023I’m kinda happy about this desu
>>268307023But Necro is a cushion in itself...
>>268307132This honestly.
>>268305276>I’ll be at the end of the magazine each week starting this issue. Please think of it as the treat that you save till the end.speculation confirmed
>>268307337>treatI hope you get axed you useless waste of space.
So possible series ending next>MHA (ending in 1 month)>psych>necro>jjk (ends this year)>yozakura (last arc)>uek>yokai buster (safe?)
>>268307132>>268307266It's the only new series with anything resembling an upwards trajectory or investment. Astro had more initial buzz but quickly cratered. If they do axe it next batch that's a big fuckup on their end.
>>268306855Arent those number higher than necro
>>268307425one piece becomes triweekly
>>268307439Depends on its sales, it'll be another GGG where x pretends it's super popular but sells like shit.Astro will underperform too, MIND YOU, but they spent actual money on it.
I had a dream where Speedy shota got axed after current arc ...
>>268307574they bought digital
>>268307582That's called a nightmare
>>268307419comments like that are why his flying squirrel picture is now a crying ghost
We need a legit cuck manga tbhdesu, it will sell like hot cakes in todays market. WSJ needs its own kanokari, that shit sells millions.
>>268307759This kind of nepotism is just not cool.
>>268305890Wasn't it Alice something?
>>268307574It would be reasonable if they waited for the Volume 1 sales to confirm anything. Lots of series, ie Anemone, aren't deemed worthy of that(and in the case of Anemone that's totally understandable)
>>268307791isn't it Nue? I don't read it but the cuckposting was cancerous
>>268306096>Ubuyashiki BomberWhat did they mean by this?
>>268307804he's had less than 30 chapters in jump, this isn't nepotism
>>268307337That's so fucking sad what the fuck
>>268308024>it's not nepotism where your series is decided from the get go to be the untouched permanent bottom after your last attempt bombed super hard and got axed
Amazon Pre order update
How much is the print of ASTRO?
>This week's weekly ShonenJump posting order & comments from the author.https://mangaplus.shueisha.co.jp/web_pages/1504/
>>268308166We'll only know on release.We still don't know KB's first print but it was supposedly big.
So Makoto GODkimura gave kagurabachi a recommendation? KGBI Won
>>268308102bro if it was nepotism they would have just given him a regular series slot and protected that, the end of magazine slot is paid lower (because of less pages) and has to be a gag manga and can still get axed
>>268308166too big considering it's tracking alongside mamayuyu >>268308114
>>268305828why are you posting last week's toc retard
>>268308240Even jp is shitting on it for nepotism, I don't know why you're pretending it's not
>I’ll be at the end of the magazine each week starting this issue. Please think of it as the treat that you save till the end. Fuck off
>>268308240>and can still get axedSay that again when its first volume does like 3k and doesn't get axed.
>>268308178someone linked it earlier but thank. can’t believe the kagurabachi author is an idolfag. i guess we all can’t have perfect tastes
>>268308367It will, they dont keep absolute flop in the magazine, if the readers dont like it, they will get rid of it, that how jump work, readers has the most power over series
>astro will sell less than 30k>wsj will still keep it despite also axing ayashimon
How come nobody is dumping Sakamoto
>>268308357Why are people assmad over this? It's kind of sad. I feel bad for him.
>>268308367gag manga live by their reception in the magazine, not by volume sales
To make people understand how bad Astro's rank is, it's neck to neck with MAMAYUYU, a 10k seller
>>268300112what do you mean by SoL standards, anon? Care to elaborate? I want to know about itAnd yeah, i think new character could spice thing up a bit At least with the new chapter we get some new lore like how nemuru is the first people that awaken his psych power, maybe it will lead into future plot point, but probably it wontI just treat psych house like yotsuba, read it for the character interaction and nice art, if there is a lore or plot development then thats a plusBut i know that kind of thing is not suited for shonen jump lol
>>268308531>inb4 people fightThey did
>>268308577axed series tend to depreciate in sales as well, so it's tracking alongside probably a 5k seller lmao
>>268308518Ayashimon ended at like volume 5 and Astro is on its track to end at that volume with its current speed run
>>268308542Doesn't mesh with SEA kiddy Muslim humor I guess, I don't get it. It's a fun cute little manga.
Kino Psych House chapter, totally didn't get the axe notice.
>>268308666>Ayashimon ended at like volume 5If by that you mean it ended at chapter 25 with 3 volumes.
>>268308577Astro will sell more than the pre order rank show since that how it’s usually go for veterans vol.1, words of mouth will do his job
Himaten looks boring
>>268308599I mean that there's still an art to making a good SoL manga. Just because a series like yotsuba doesn't have a lot of drama or high impact comedy going on doesn't mean it's BORING. If your SoL manga is edging too hard into boring then you've fucked something up.
>>268308806ah okay For some reason I thought it lasted much longer
>>268305828This is last weeks TOC dumbshit. Elusive Samurai is the lead cover.
>>268308599Yotsubato had yotsuba, what does this manga has going for it?
https://may.2chan.net/b/res/1233722650.htm2chan thread
>>268308816 I'm astrofag and even I don't think it can pass that with the amount of doomposting it got
Astro is slowly regaining its feet in recent chapters but it may be already too late
>>268308835They're trying to replicate blue box
It's time
>yozakura thread already deadThis series went from exist to murdered in broad daylight
>>268308745Hope it lasts there. If I'm understanding correctly he took the voluntary bottom ToC for a better safety cushion in exchange.
>>268309292It just doesn't have dedicated schizobumper who will keep the thread alive from page 10 every time.
>>268309292It's just not a popular one it's a forever exister but that's fine honestly.
>>268309292It's wsj, existing already means winning now
>>268309424It used to have one but he threw in the towel.
Voted, see ya next week.4th: Sakamoto Days5th: Kyokuto Necromance
>>268309292seems the same as ever to me
>>268309595Disgusting.
>>268309595Commendable.
Oh so Necromance and Bucket are like DEAD dead.
>>268302049her powers could make the world a little less boring like when she burned that guy's hair
>>268309595Based
>>268309823Bucket yes
>>268309897Necromance too, they basically had the same debut.
Are we really going to get 3 U19s in a row
>>268305203thank you
What went wrong with Bucket, it was the most hyped by /a/ in the batch
>>268309928You're comparing within a limited framework. Bucket ranked under a Chapter 3 of Necro. Necro made the cut for Tsugimanga, Bucket did not. Bucket is comparable to Anemone(likely worse), Necro to GGG(likely over).
>>268309725Literally why do this manga even exist?
>>268309967We aren't, but we SHOULD.
>>268310017>Cool concept>Cool first 3 chapters>Do nothing with it
>>268310017The plot is going nowhere
>>268310022Necro only ranked above a series axed the same issue.Necro is dead, it's three chapters in and hasn't left bottom 2.
>>268309967A month ago I would have been sad about bucket going but it's lost me. Necromance never had me in the first place, and lets not talk about Astro. Somehow the newer batch feels stronger even though it's literally two gag exorcist series back to back and some generic sounding romance. Murokami and Kiyoshi are the only manga out of the last 5 debuts that I'm still enjoying at this point.
>>268310087>>268310077it's SoL, what is supposed to be the plot
>>268310116kyoshi was much better than i expected, it's basically mashle 2
>>268310143Maybe but I like my stories to have plot desu
>>268310143you need to have a plot in SoL even if it's something as simple as "reconnecting with family members", or "Rival Psych hates new girl and plays pranks"
>>268310017The last couple chapters have just felt tedious and uninteresting. It's a bad sign when it feels like the author already gave up after the first 3-4 chapters.
>>268310017I like, it's a comfy SoL and the characters are cute. Sadly, it seems it's doomed.
>>268307452
>>268310101This is again tying into what I said about the limited framework. It was a very early round leading into Necro's ranking. Necro would be above GGG, DA, and Bucket consistently, maybe under GGG at most. That's a standard dead-end debut, not something as monumental as people are making it out to be. Bucket is immediate bottom material and as dead as can be. If they only axe one series from the batch next wave it will be Bucket.
>>268310249>you need to have a plot in SoL
>>268310336so uh I was somewhat right i guess?
>>268310336>people ask themselves why necro is ranking like shitReminder that jump+ views for the first three chapters have a strong correlation with popularity and sales.
>>268310039to teach the children thingsstudy jump got us a naputaaku one shot so i'm not complaining
Witch Watch>>268305647
>>268307425>possible series ending next>MHA (ending in 1 month)>possible they announced the date and issue it will end in
>>268310394You need to be entertaining, charming, or funny; if not, the axe is inevitable
>>268307439>draw a woman call it a man
>>268310554I found it to be all those three things, but I'll just chalk it up to japanese being retards, as usual.
>>268310458Isn't kindergarten for that? I don't see any of those manga selling well at all
>>268310540That’s why it says>(ending in 1 month)
>>268307759that squirrel died? that's so sad...
>>268310585It's jump, bucket would be fine in any other magazine when your average sol isn't selling anything beyond 10k.
>>268310017it had the best first chapter of the batch and the opening chapters after were good but it's losing steam. The paneling isn't dynamic enough and the dialog isn't snappy enough to carry the content. Took too long just getting Kotone moved in and introducing new characters one after the other. Too many chapters take place in the house. There's no educational angle like a lot of SoL has. I think this mangaka needs plot for his work to shine, he doesn't have the chops to make SoL engaging. He should do a romcom next.
>>268310597i think kindergarten is more for learning even more basic things, study jump is like elementary school level things for specific topics
>>268309524tragic
>>268310682But series are boosted by being in Jump in the first place, so Bucket would only perform that much worse
>>268310017>it was the most hyped by /a/ in the batchironic memes
>>268310964That's not how that works but ok.
>>268310645should've been separate subcategories desu
>>268298978Where's my Toyosloppo?
>>268310458>to teach children thingsWhat were they trying to teach them with this?
>>268300112>Ruri has also kinda felt like it's been in a rut latelySoooooooo...business as usual for Ruri. It never left that rut. Though I can't disagree that Bucket need to do something. It's still a better manga than Ruri with a cast that's actually had some development, but it's also feeling pretty aimless.
speaking of rurihas a schedule for the next batch of chapters been released?mangaplus says the next one is july 14 but will it be consistent after that?
>>268311162To fuck egyptian gyaru?
>>268310882I thought jump was already for elementary school children
>>268301593Bro, serious question, why even expect anything is going to happen? How many times have readers for this manga believed that something was going to happen yet it never did?>Oh! An umbrella with a katana handle! I bet it was actually Human Mommy's sword and she was a great hero at one point!>Nevermind. It's actually just an umbrella.>Ruri's teacher mentioned other unique people! I bet there's other hybrids out there and Ruri will meet them real soon!>Nope. Not a single hybrid to be seen, and supposedly Ruri's the only one.See what I mean? I really think you're getting your hopes up for nothing.
>>268311075Yes it is? Jump is tied to the biggest properties and its series get more eyes on it. If there was no benefit to running in Jump in the first place and Bucket would've been so successful in a different magazine, authors wouldn't try getting published in it. What's a 5K flop in Jump can just be a 1K flop in Sunday.
>>268311162how to raise a bitch
>>268311307yeah, but these series are educational unlike those in weekly shonen jump
>>268311497Magazines have different audiences idiot and this was clearly pushed on the author, most sol writers do not try for jump at all and stay comfortable in other magazines selling less.
Would Ruri sell double if it was in a different magazine?
>>268311606>His genre and concept was forced on him and he was forced to do it at JumpThe delusion is unreal, especially when your dumb ass already forgot that Ruri exists.
>>268311746not one bit, the only reason it sells this much without an anime is because it's got the exposure of Jump
>>268311746No
>>268311752Retard forgot how many views the oneshot got. It's a massive exception that never would've been serialized otherwise.
>>268311162>gyaru Egyptian lolliUWOAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH
>>268308114Oof anemone
>>268311835My mistake, I'll have to check out what publisher was behind Ruri Dragon's one-shot!
>>268311746If it wasn't for Jump, I don't think it would sell even a fraction as well. While I do think there are Jump series that would have done well even without Jump, I don't Ruri would have been one of them.
>>268311928You genuinely think it would've been serialized if it didn't get all that attention beforehand? When the author's winning gfc entry was a completely different genre?
>>268311835What even was so special about the oneshot? I mean, it's better than the serialization (not like that's saying much), but I always thought it was alright at best.
>>268312014You're just throwing out tangental facts to dilute from the fact that YES a series being in Jump means it has a much bigger initial audience than anything else in Jump and YES SoL has success in Jump in terms of sales and TOC. Of course if it had zero impact it wouldn't make it in, but it made it in because it got attention and it has no much initial attention because it was a Jump product.There can be magazines where SoL is the norm and more of the audience is receptive to Bucket, but at that point it still has to stand on its own merits against other SoL and the potential audience has been greatly reduced.
>>268300951I usually read things based on the batch they started, from newest to oldest, then tackle even older things in whatever order I feel like.For example, today is Kiyoshi first, then Murakami, then I'll go somewhat randomly among Necromance/Astro/Cycle, then Choujo, and after that it's a free-for-all. The only consistency is I start with OP and I'll read Nue and KGB side-by-side for console-war reasons.
>>268298978Kill all cucksKill all used goods heroinesKill nue cucks
>>268312204>There can be magazines where SoL is the norm and more of the audience is receptive to BucketThere you go retard. You can acknowledge that so there's no point in trying to argue Bucket would be giga dead in other magazines. Bucket isn't any worse than the typical sol, it would do fine had it not been in Jump.
BucketSCHOLAR LOST
>>268312815RuriTRANNIES lose everytime a new chapter comes out because nothing happens.
Why does MHA rarely get dumped?Anyways Kagurabachi won this issue
>>268312941>t. bandwagoning retard who only started reading it because it was popular
>>268313015because /a/ gave up on MHA years ago. The finale thread will reach bump limit just shit talking the series.
>>268313096What are you babbling about?
>>268313169>t. retard
>>268312365No, actual retard, you've acknowledged that being SoL does not spell death for a Jump series. Bucket would have an even smaller initial audience, that's all that matters and that's why someone wants to risk Jump in the first place. Not hard for everybody besides you in this thread to grasp.
2chan threadhttps://may.2chan.net/b/res/1233722650.htmhttps://may.2chan.net/b/res/1233747467.htm
>>268313374You conceded there can be magazines where sol is the norm and be more receptive to Bucket, shut the fuck up already. Bombing in jump doesn't automatically doom Bucket everywhere else when it's by no means a bad sol manga.
>>268313564Bucketards have to be the most manic, overly sensitive axebait lovers since Fabricant or Asumi.
>>268306185it looks good. it's plot is easy to understand. also celebrity voice actors (in japan).it's the same reason why the mcu was popular in 'murica.that's all what it takes.
>>268313564You could say this shit about any other axed series in jump, it's very easy when you live in the world of 'what if"
What was bucket about this chapter? I dropped it after 5 pages.
>>268313742Last point I don't agree on, didn't the MCU kickstart the career of several actors?
>>268313754It's an avant garde series about a psych ward with roughly 500 patients except they all escaped into the real world and made up its fanbase
>>268313754We had Kaiju bee
>>268313805It had Robert Downey Jr, an industry vet, who was casted as Iron Man. His father already had a huge legacy as a film maker and actor. Every single actor a part of the Avengers in Phase One has been active since 2002. But they are playing iconic characters, so I'd be lying if I said that the legacy of those superheroes didn't carry some of their careers.
>>268313742it's simple and it has a clear start and ending, unironically being finished is what helped Kimetsu, it's a generational series for the japanese
>>268313279Want to clarify what you mean? I'm afraid I don't speak retard.
>>268313754hinted at bucket boy's tragic backstory of exploding his mom when he was born by using his grow big power on himself
>>268314398newfag
>>268314410it also hinted at bucket's cannibalism and the origin of his bucket
>>268314226Wasn't Robert Downey jr career in the gutter at that point because of his addictions?
>>268313843That description makes it sound too much like something actually happened. The whole chapter was spent just enlarging and shrinking flowers; the bee problem solved itself without them having to do anything.
>>268314438Can't say more than one word? I'm sorry. I realize now I was picking on someone who can't form complete sentences. I'm really sorry about that. I think it's best we go our separate ways and forget this ever happened. You go back to reading those "I Can Read" books, and I'll be here discussing manga, okay? Off you go, then.
>>268310336>Astro royale is gonna liveJUST NUKE JAPAN.
>>268315306what's wrong with astro? it's starting off way better than TR
>>268315342No it's not?TR had a great hook and a proper mystery. Takemichi was also kinda ok in the beginning.Astro is just bland, completely squandered its setting and Hibari is terrible.
>>268315306Nuke fujos, to death.
>>268315409>TR had a great hook and a proper mystery.And how did that go? Right.
>>268315198try to hide your newfaggotry better next time
>>268315492>STARTING OFFIt went to shit, sure, but it was pretty good until the Christmas arc ended.Way better than astro from the get go too
>>26831549280m
Who won this thread?
>>268315306>Astro royale is gonna liveReminder this managed to die. There's no hope for Astro.
>>268315533*Gasp* He formed a full sentence! Bravo! Oh, bravo! I knew you could do it!Now, seriously, off you go. You're shitting up this thread.
>>268315607Everyone since there hasn't been any stale shitposting spam
>>268315625Jump was kind of dumb if they did axe Ichinose, tbf. Astro meanwhile has already collapsed pre-Volume 1, it seems more like a Sam 8 flop than an Ichinose bleed.
>>268315607Bejita.
>>268315658>they did axe Ichinose, tbf.Horrid reception and bleeding sales.
>>268315625I actually forgot Ichinose used to pull some really good numbers. Just makes its death even harsher in the end.
>>268315440I didn't know you could nuke them without killing them
>>268315640why are you typing like a tranny?
>>268315658Were you not reading it at the time? It was a shitshow
>>268315697If I remember correctly, its reception wasn't that bad when it started, but I think it was around the whole, "this was all a dream" twist that its reception started to decline. The first volume sold pretty decently, too, but each one was selling less. It's too bad. The mystery behind the family having collective amnesia was an interesting setup, but the whole series just became such a clusterfuck by the end.
>>268315736Why are you still here? I'm done with you. Either discuss Jump series or fuck off.
>I'm down with you>still repliesruri haters are truly the most retarded of creatures
>>268304302are all the good artists in JUMP+ now? raputa's is far above all garbage wsj has published in the past few years, at least so far
>>268315910Can't even type out what I said correctly. Freakin' hilarious. Also, you got it wrong. Ruri fanboys are the most retarded of creatures, which you've shown yourself to be. Now get out of here and stop shitting up this thread. Unlike you, I actually am trying to discuss manga here.
So, Astro apparently isn't too great from what I've heard, but what about Tokyo Revengers? I've been thinking about checking it out sometime. Is it better than Astro and is it worth checking out?
>>268315834>Jump seriesRetard, Ruri is still a Jump series. If you mean Weekly Shonen Jump then say Weekly Shonen Jump.
>>268316194Guys, the parrot's squawking again! How do I get it to shut up?
>>268308878Nemuru who's pretty funny and likable? Kotone, who's hot and has perkier boobs thanks to Nemuru? Yotsuba is a great manga, though. Still waiting for volume 16.
>>268308114GGGbros we're gonna outsell Kagurabachi!!! We can make it back to Jump!!!
>>268316097It has an interesting concept but it shits the bed to the point where explaining it as shitting the bed is too kind.It's a generation fuckup.
The new batch is doing terribly in japan
>>268316629Damn. That's harsh. Would you say it's still worth checking out even knowing that it shits the bed later?
>>268315671he got his plant porn he really did win
>>268316727yes because it's magazine's fault that TR shit the bed, not Wakui's
>>268315910>I'm down with youkeep it in your pants anon
>>268316793Always do. Bejita always wins, baby.
>>268315697Yes, Ichinose had a bleed, but it still managed to outsell the vast majority of series and the dropoff was leveling out. What was always overlooked, largely on account of people here relying on 4-week charts from Reddit, was that Ichinose had crazy legs. It sold to an audience that was not in synch with typical Jump cadence, and naturally had a big digital audience to boot. Jump axed it for the decline and lack of magazine reader interest while investing hope in 30K sellers showing minor growth that have since stagnated, ie KB.>>268315751I was. The format seemed more suitable for binge reading.
>>268316813Alright. I think I will check it out sometime. Thanks, Anon.
>>268303393So many chapters ended with "oh, they fucks" this week.>Blue Box>Sakamoto>Ruri Dragon
>>268316850no shit. anon could have at least taken him out to dinner first
>>268316697>be me>look up "cushion gif">not expecting much>the dream is over>lmao somebody edit the new batch onto homer's face
>>268316697
>>268316867>volume buyers and magazine readers can be separate>magazine reader pull can be more important than salesPeople don't want to accept these two facts, that's why ichinose legs are overlooked in favor of the first month charts.
>>268317327The charts shouldn't be relevant at all in that case since it doesn't always reflect the market. Going off of 4-weeks it was still on par with existers, it just passed them during the time afterwards. There's definitely something to be said for TOC and magazine sales, but Jump clearly operated under the basis that they knew Ichinose's growth was stunted and bet on series taking off that didn't. It was a net loss for them.
>>268310017/a is full of retardsthey called kgb axebait and now it's the manga with most potential and they called bucket the next big thing and now it's axebaitalways do the opposite of /a tards
>>268317476There are those like myself who are very intelligent though, so listen to people like me. I knew KGB would be big because of its global reception. Something a 2chan-translating retard ITT had a hard time grasping, as he was comparing the popularity to that of Red Hood.
>>268316356The thief and the nothing burger, what a combo you have here!
>>268316543Making it back to jump is actually a real thing, look it up jamie
>>268316727Yeah, just stop reading after the wedding, you have been warned
>>268317718After the wedding. Alright. Thanks, Anon.
>>268317563Nah nobody knows for sure, you always get one wrong, eventually
>>268317463Mfw will look at this chart and still think that ichinose had a chance, cope harder, it went from outselling most of the mag to UU numbers. LOL
ASStro will be the new Blacked Clover.
>>268317957
>>268317655The thief with a nice chest and ass and the Bucketlord, you mean.
>>268317957If you don't know what legs are don't bother trying to join the conversation
>>268308835The romcom will be the only survivor of this batch
>>268308835it looks generic but japanese love generic crap
>>268317861I know, I'm kidding. But I did want to name and shame the "only japan matters" posters that KGB has since transmogrified into "KGB is over" doomposters out of shame
>>268318109Wut that still holds true. KGBfags have been spending all this time stressing over japan-side metrics and ignoring mangaplus performance. They're still quite aware japan is what matters in the end.
>>268318326It's marketed as an international hit, and the success came about in Japan because of international interest. The ones that are actually stressing about its performance and whether it will live give off newfriend vibes.
What is even the point in arguing about KGB success now, when Vol3 pre-orders point at stagnation? It had its chance, 39 chapters are the solid hook for hundreds thousands of WSJ readers, but even with all the word of mouth general shounen reading audience just didnt take that hook.If it was such a potential pillar, by Vol3 hundreds thousands people should have been onto it and boost the fuck out of the sales.They didnt.Its literally over unless anime in couple years will be great and people finally pick it up.
>>268318716Reminder, vol.2 sold out by 3rd week and reprints are still charting today.If World Trigger was considered success in 2013, then KGB is on another level because it outsold WT considerably.
>>268318054Oh I know, sadly if you don't bring up any data to back you up in claiming that it had good legs, then you only end up looking like a clown.Also those legs don't matter all that much if they were getting 1k a week and bring in the 400s lol
>>268318716df you talking about you schizothe vol are selling better than everything except top 4 in wsjand when mha and jjk end all the readers will automatically head towards kgb
>>268318831We are probably getting reprints as soon as week 2, if not end of week 1, this time around week 3 and 4 are going to be the deciding weeks for KGBI
>>268318870This is not 100% true, they can always go and read Sakamoto or another mag, only time can tell
>>268318834Go back to the relevant threads in the archive, it's a pain in the ass to compile. You clearly either weren't there at the time or were one of the people being willfully ignorant of those legs given that you're comparing it to UU. After the first week or so of a month the Ichinose volume from the previous month would be ranking over UU, lmao.
>>268319140I wasn't there at the time, true, but if those legs had actually been fucking mind shattering maybe we would still have ichinose with us today; but we dont, thus, they weren't all that great. Maybe they went from doing UU numbers to doing yozakura numbers before it stop charting? Yeah that's not good either, lol, cope harder
should shindo upload 1-2 pages short chapters on the offweeks like other J+ series?
>>268319261It roughly doubled its sales in the following month and a half on average. It was performing above Akane longterm(including the sales Akane gained over that same duration). You don't have to act like Jump is run by geniuses. They killed a series for dipping when it didn't dip below the numbers from a bulk of series dragging their feet. >I wasn't there at the time, trueThis was all that needed to be said.
That is it. Fuck this shit. I'm going to send an entry to WSJ, someone has to save this goddamn magazine.
>>268318870>and when mha and jjk end all the readers will automatically head towards kgbkgbfags are so toddlers lmao
>>268319319Graffitis on the twitter would be better, it feels too professional with only chapter updates
>>268319568You will never be a mangaka
>>268319419Claims without proof are worthless bitch, better luck next time
>>268320187Again, newfag, go to the archives. I wasted too much time doing that when it was relevant to do it for someone actively admitting that they're ignorant on the topic(which at least put you one step above other retards ITT)
>4th highest WSJ pre-order rn (only 1 point behind TES (upcoming anime btw))>48th on general ranking in Rakuten>Volume 3 back summary went viral in japan cause of how cool it wasnow we just need the PV and the rec reveal
>>268320629>only to get fucked by insanely low print (unless they were just lying I guess)
bucket needs new boy already.the house having bucket as the only male pysch and he only interacts with girls will make the manga is harem.
>>268320710Palestine reads Astro? Maybe they do deserve an ethnic cleansing
>>268320824Just wait for the chapter where Nemuru uses his Psych on his cock. Kotone and the other girls won't be able to resist the girth of the Bucketgod.
>>268299208I don't think mangaka like yakimura will even recommend violent revenge manga like KGB lol
>>268306393But it's funny when Mashle is massively overpowered, when this guy is it's just boring, which is a shame because I like everything outside the fights
>>268320824its mamayuyu replacement
>>268315625Ichinose is the best thing Jump has shit out in the past 10 years.
>>268320315I already know Im right but fuck it, just to dunk harder on you here it isShoseki Ranking Top 500 (October 31)2. Jujutsu Kaisen 24111. Blue Box 12156. Mashle 18223. Akane-banashi 8357. Witch Watch 13377. Nue's Exorcist 1462. Ichinose-ke no Taizai 4498. Undead Unluck 18By end of the month volume 4 was already at the 400s, where do you think the rest of the volumes were? Again, cope harder
>>268321567No it wasn't lmao
>>268321981Cope, bachitard
>>268321942Feel free to keep tracking it, odds are it proceeds to fluctuate and spike on weekends for the forseeable future. But v4 is around the rush/axe era, I was talking Volume 2-3 numbers especially.
>>268308904I like how nips think KGB is like Ninja Slayer.
>Jump thread on page 9What killed the hype?
>>268323344SHITro exists.
>>268318831Eh, WT was LIVE tier. The real successes were the +100k hitters like AssClass and Shokugeki.
>>268323458If they weren't so obsessed with monthly reprints we probably would get 100k+ pretty easily
>>268323394SHITro? That's what you're going with? C'mon, ASStro was right there.
>>268323344the only 100k+ sellers are either ending or are triweekly
>>268323458>EXIST tierftfy
Astro didn't get dump thread? Even TRfujo are giving up?
>>268323745
Are we charting, kgbrats? Can't wait for Oricon thread.
>>268323344no one cares about kekmagazine outside op, jjk, mha.
>>268323344magu ending
>>268323344Copbot chapter
>>268321567>>268322129>throwing out terrible cliffhangers every 3 chaptersretard.
Kill Blue somehow got a chapter dumb that lasted a while.
>>268324485Dump*
>>268319319guy is so lazy that make axeman looks like the most diligent author in j+.
Murakami just looks like a source of merch if you ask me. Either plushies or real trading cards of the chibi Yokai.
>>268303070this starts remind me of snk kek.>everything out there will fuck human>but by somehow human still can make villages>maybe the world is not what it seems?
My favorites this week were KGB, Necro and surprisingly, Kiyoshi. I hope Kiyoshi can pick up additional views domestically. The comedy works for me, love the art. Feels like the next Mashle with a more expressive MC.>Necro feels like it's panicking and headed for a potentially early exit sadly>Bucket is kinda losing me, it needs more comedy or snappier dialog of spicier paneling or something>Chojo isn't among my favorites but it had a good chapter this week>Roboco is NOT doing the harem gyaru romcom and I'm disappointed!>Might pick up Nue again, latest chapters actually look kinda interesting
Which series had the worst chapter this issue?
Natsucomi 2024,Titles recommended:"Killuao", "Nue's Exorcist"
>>268326000based, love this series.
>>268325990Nue and Bucket.
>>268326000>two Natsucomi bookmarks for every purchase of the following comics
>>268325990>>268326115You're dumb, it was that stupid Yokai Buster manga.It's so slow paced for such a boring punchline.
>>268325990Murakami is snorefest. I like Kiyoshi much better.I hope Murakami dies in winter batch.
>>268326000Asai keeps winning
>>268308367>when its first volume does like 3kCopium. The Murakami gravy train has only just gotten started and it's never slowing down.
>>268326000>zombie>zombiezzzzzzzzzzzz
>>268323344Unironically 6 (SIX) wsj threads reaching bump limit back to back for the past few days since toc was posted, thanks to kbgtards and nuefags.
>>268323344Because these threads exist to be kgbg2 and everything else is called a zombie. It doesn't lend itself to any discussion other than shitflinging.
>>268326000You can also buy volumes outside of the natsucomi event like Kagurabachi to get a bookmark of your choice but you need to buy at least 2 comics
Man July 4th really is kinda stacked for Volume releases huhOne PieceJujutsuOPMKaiju #8Dandadan
Nue has the best chapter this week, the fight has been extraordinary
>>268307337I guess if it's meant to get special treatment that would explain them doing 2 comedy exorcist manga together, one of them doesn't count
>>268309524Just look at >>268301369, one post every 30-60 minutes and you're golden.
>>268323344Page 10 now.
>>268323344>>268329032jjk and mha not even dead yet....
>>268328014Holy shit that's embarrassing.
Amazon pre order update
>>268329322TES anime should be aired this week, right?
>>268326000Why is it always these two together
>>268329322ASStro......
>Amazon
>>268329322Astro...FLOP
>>268329322>Shitstro still below robocoJuly is going to be so fun
>>268329352batchmates
>Muh Astro flopperinoKGB vol.1&2 couldn't even surpass Astro. What a disappointment.
>>268329457that's how they're ranking now, dipshitmonths after release. the fact they're holding on at all is a miracle.
>>268329457I'm more disappointed that Astro tankoubon didn't get 2 digits while KGB got it.
>>268329322>Astro above everyone is RakutenThe Astro sweep will be funny this July, kgbtard, nuefag and shitters crying kek
>>268329885>Astro above everyone is Rakuten it's below robocoOP - 1JJK - 2KGB - 45Akane - 62WW - 119TES - 166Nue - 263Roboco - 418Astro - 533
>>268329917those were yesterdays numbers iircit's above most things now, but rakuten tend not to stock more than 1000 copies of a series (unless you're wan piss or jjk) so i wouldn't put much stock in it meaning anything
>>268329917Cope Astro is above your slop and you will cry in July
>>268329947>>268330056...no it's still below pretty much everything
>there was already an open and active WSJ thread>people didn't like that thread anyway and created this instead>they let that thread die instead and moved hereI don't even get the point.
>>268330117>Astro - 10>Kgb - 16Cry you are getting btfo in 3 days
>>268329351July 6 (this Saturday).
>>268330477>kgb out of NOWHEREhokazono won btw
>>268330477>it's nowhere to be seen on the actual latest rankOkay champ
>>268330627Not even wanting to defend astro, but it's out of stock there.
>>268329322Everyone is over exaggerating with the astro doomposting. Is going to do fine (if it does 30-20k that's fine but it should have better standards because of the mangaka). We should instead focus on the volume 2 & 3 growth/decline.
>>268330825Yes, above 20k Is good for jump (but trashy if you take into account his previous million seller series)
Watch out about frontload, Chojun got similar Amazon rank as Kill blue and Yoza just to make 14k in the end
>>268323745Scroll up blindbri
>Nice art >Likable MC>funny joke>good actionwhy the fuck you faggots hate Kyoshi so much
>>268331112I like Kiyoshi
>>268331112Nobody hate it, but J+ stats are axebait material sadlyIt’s the same things that happened to Necromance
>>268331112I like it and I'm salty that Yokai Buster is most likely going to outlive it due to the immunity bullshit.It's David all over again.
>>268330825Its doomposting for sure, it'll do fine. However the expectations were higher than your average new series, Jump clearly paid out to get this one and were giving it an extra push. Still think it will last a while regardless and probably not sell worse than the majority of the magazine. But the magazine doesn't need another middling series it can't really get rid of.
>>268315671>>268316793>>268316856Maybe we will get another U19 too with new EiC, meaning Bejita's wife also won.
>>268331112I don't like it that much. Why go with the he's scared premise if it gets resolved in one chapter? He's just one exorcist man now. In the second chapter he didn't have any problem wasting the second demon lord. So first he's a coward and today he's just socially awkward.
>>268331720>ch.1 sets up he stops being scared when he has to protect someone>isn't scared when he's protecting classmates in ch.2Try reading the words on the page next time anon
the only Ichinosefag in captivity
>>268331632Well, I hope Goku will be able to win and his new favorite Jump manga, Psych House will somehow manage to bounce back.
>>268331813Okay so he's just the most powerful exorcist then
>>268308178so toc doesn't matter for Murakami? i guess it'll live then.shame, i think kiyoshi is the better exorcist comedy
Is Kagurabachi confirmed to have trilogy movies for final arc?
>>268331918>literally just the infinity castlei dont get how anyone could read the currently jump lineup and think nue is a better fit for ufo than kgb
>>268317463anon, ichinose was clearly cut short given the ending. clearly it wasn't doing well. there's just no slicing it, what's the point in defending the sales of an axed series
Kagurabachi Obi almost got leaked but we don’t see shit, there look like blond haired characters
>>268331981>>toriyama recommending kaguraboogie from beyond the grave
>>268331981IS THAT FUCKING NARUTO????
>>268310017most of the initial hype was pretty much just ironic shitposting, then chapter 1 came out and it was better than people expected so it started gaining some kind of fandom... and then the first toc placement had it being dead last.coupled with a few uninteresting chapters people just dropped the sinking ship
>>268331981HOLY FUCK AKIRA TORIYAMA??
>>268331981That look like Naruto lmao
>>268331981TORIYAMACHADS WE WON
>Kagurabachi getting the Kishi co-signWould be kind of poetic, considering the other WSJ series he recommended is on its way out in a few issues. Kind of passing the torch.
>>268331981
>>268332137what other series did he rec
>>268331981OH NO NO NO NO NO
>>268331981>Series name begins with either an 'N' >Yellow hairFuck yeah, I think we know where this is going
>>268332146MHA, back when it was just starting up
You fools...
>>268331981So when full reveal?
>>268331981>Pedo author>Main blond characterBEHOLD
>>268332162It could also be a M.
>>268332293Mamayuyubros...
>>268331981>did you miss me?
>for my final decree as editor in chief>i have enlisted IKEMOTO to recommend kagurabachi
>>268331981nuebros.... not like this
>>268332403>The pure melty that would ensue Please
>>268332144
>>268331918>Hinao (traitor turned good) vs female Hishaku sorceress>Hakuri's asspull vs zombie Souyabean's asspull>Hiyuki, Chihiro, and one of the enchanted blade user vs male hishaku samurai>Last, everyone gangrape farmerhishaku( forma de EL HERMANO)
>>268331981FTchads...
>>268331981>Dat hairlineLooks like Kishi's drawing.
>>268331981vidya obi
>>268331981Nuebros?? I thought Nasu loves our mango?
>>268331981/co/ here
>>268311162reproduce with brown gyaru
>>268331981roxasGODS we fuarking WON
>>268331981That could be Zenitsu, you know.
https://itest.5ch.net/kizuna/test/read.cgi/wcomic/1719820901
>>268331112One Joke Man 3: a new exorcist
>>268332705Based
>>268332780was that posted by a demon
>>268332854It's 5ch. So yes.
>>268331981>recs from kishimoto and horikoshii think we're back
>>268305890>>268307839Otogi no Ibitsu
>>268331981This motherfcker chose this angle where we can only see a glimps of the character on purpose
>>268332916Was that lastest illustration by Kishi?
>>268332916This anon just confirmed it now
What Rec did Astro get? Was it revealed?
>>268333020>wakui>getting a recWould be insulting.
>>268333020A Wakui rec
>>268333020>implying an 80M seller mangaka needs a recit'd be like giving gotouge one
Looks like Wakui "need" saving. Give poor little soul Wakui a rec please.
>>268333020it got a kgb rec
>>268331981KgbRATs will get Pierrot Film.
>>268333096Astro only needs Wakui to stop holding back
kagura is actually going to pierrot after all, isn't it?
>>268333250Bleach TYBW last cour looks kino doebeit.
>>268333212Actually kino
When did we start hating Pierrot? Isn't that they're the solid choice for battle shonen adaptation.
Behito.
>>268333423Bejito ? Won.
>>268333439>>268333439>>268333439
>>268333421>naruto>bleach>yu yu
>>268330555Eight-year-old Tokiyuki Houjou, the next successor of the Kamakura shogunate, is a young boy (...)>boyFuuuuuuuuuuuuuck
>>268335037You just realized that now?
>>268333441kill yourself
>>268335253I don't keep up with these threads. Saw the character in the thumbnail and thought "cute!" but alas
>>268335407I mean Tokiyuki's still cute
The Elusive Samurai won.
