[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities

Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]

[Catalog] [Archive]

File: Explaining_Hitler.jpg (23 KB, 220x317)
23 KB
23 KB JPG
Adolf Hitler was totally convinced jews were evil and he had to stop them, doesn't that mean he was doing the right thing? It would be no more immoral than a doctor who makes a diagnosis based on the information available at the time which later turns out to be wrong. The only way Hitler could be evil is if he knowingly sowed his spooks amongst the populace without actually believing any of it.
I think our hysteria over Hitler and the nazis is just a way of pretending evil is some comical caricature that doesn't apply to us, so we can say "it's not fascism when we do it".
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Explaining_Hitler
>>
>>16445869
>doctor makes diagnosis that turns out to be wrong
Then that's called a shitter.

File: 1668878653770267.jpg (64 KB, 581x542)
64 KB
64 KB JPG
Do mass inmigration historically end up in civil wars?
14 replies and 1 image omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>16445746
Conservative minorities vote for Dems because you openly want to murder them, not because they're really "on the left".
Most leftists are young, college educated whites.

If you cooled it with the wanting to kill black people and send hispanics to concentration camps you could probably win elections legitimately.
>>
>>16445746
I'm white and my parents, most of their friends, most of my friends, and most of my friends parents are left of center and unconcerned with race politics, although there is noticeable self segregation, there aren't actually any political issues which the different races in my state can't readily come to a productive agreement on. There's a slight mismatch of political signals but it's reconciled quickly when brought up
>>
>>16445701
>I'm a pan asian nationalist
there are better ways of saying you are retarded
>>
>>16445759
?????

Niggers will vote democrat because they know they have free reign to commit violent crimes with zero prosecution and get free gibs through unfair programs like affirmative action.

There is no “just treat them fairly”. The Republican platform is equal treatment under law, the Democratic platform is worshipping and glorifying niggers and giving them maximum handouts in exchange for votes.

Don’t get it twisted.
>>
>>16445775
>im a passive self hating cuckold who immediately fall in line with what DNC talking heads tell us to do

Yeah you’re docile sheep and we brown people don’t respect you.

File: 1531528138239.jpg (1.01 MB, 2000x1252)
1.01 MB
1.01 MB JPG
Drop interesting photos or arts from Fascist Italy period (futurism, architecture,posters etc.)
73 replies and 65 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>16445817
>>
File: 1656230689915.jpg (303 KB, 1200x1594)
303 KB
303 KB JPG
>>16445825
>>
File: 1681545252291116.jpg (116 KB, 736x694)
116 KB
116 KB JPG
>>
>>16445268
>>16445265
PVRE KINO
>>
File: 1678014823021960.jpg (2 MB, 3045x2126)
2 MB
2 MB JPG
Luxury interior of WW2 battleship "Roma"

File: Mountrushmore.jpg (59 KB, 600x450)
59 KB
59 KB JPG
Were they really the four best Presidents at the time of Rushmore's construction? It seems at the very least, Wilson was a more monumental President than Roosevelt.
45 replies and 2 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>16445792
You know exactly what events from last February I'm referring to. Now answer my question.
>>
>>16445800
Wtf... based grant?
>>
>>16445813
>le falsehoods
>>16445822
>le contrarianism
Enjoy Hell, Protestant scum.
>>
>>16445816
>You know exactly what events from last February I'm referring to
The thing Republicans voted against? It's inconsequential now, why even bring this up to me?
>Now answer my question
I did already dummy >>16445729
>>
>>16445843
Get out, Ellis Islander. Don't speak to an American like that.

>Look up 1st century Christianity, expect to read about some boring shit
>instead it's dozens of sects all with completely different interpretations of Jesus
>we could have had a fusion of Christianity with the Pythagoreans and Greek mysteries
>we could have had the Roman pantheon with the Christian god at the head
>esoteric interpretations of Christianity galore
>Christian sex rituals too
>but
>almost none of the early Christians look anything like modern Christianity
How the fuck did we end up with the most boring possible version of this religion?
226 replies and 27 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>16434642
Christ saves those people from hades following his crucifixion .
You have no excuse, on the other hand.
>>
>>16424611
>Look up 1st century Christianity, expect to read about some boring shit
>instead it's dozens of sects all with completely different interpretations of Jesus
protestantism
For me, the best ending would be Gnostic with the subsequent fusion with Buddhism. Christianity (and Abrahamism in general) is Buddhism for foolish people.
>>
>>16441616
nor in the same vain of Christianity and no central authority was established and different factions continuing without adhering to such councils, establishing their own orders
All the chaotic strain simply carry on their own paths and the religion "fully realize itself"(whatever it means) without being beholden to any central authority
>>
>>16445118
>Christianity (and Abrahamism in general) is Buddhism for foolish people.
And Buddhism is abrahamism for midwits. There is no dharma, you're going to be ok.
>>
>>16442609
There's no honest argument when you get down to it. It's either you accept certain canons/traditions or you dont.

>Paul and Mark were decisive in yet another matter of inestimably wide import. It was a result of Paul’s mission that, contrary to all the initial probabilities, Greek became the language of the Church and — following the lead of the first Gospel — of a sacred Greekliterature. Let the reader consider what this meant, in one way and another. The Jesus Church was artificially separated from its spiritual origins and attached to an alien and scholarly element. Touch with the folk spirit of the Aramaean motherland was lost. Thenceforward both the cult churches possessed the same language, the same conceptual traditions, the same book literature from the same schools. The far less sophisticated Aramaic literatures of the East — the truly Magian, written and thought in the language of Jesus and his companions — were cut off from cooperating in the life of the Church. They could not be read, they dropped out of sight, and finally they were forgotten altogether.

File: bccnigger.jpg (19 KB, 720x405)
19 KB
19 KB JPG
maybe its time to stop whatever you are doing and go read a book.
some of you are so fucking stupid that it hurts my mental state
>>
>>16444159
Who mage you God of /his/ desu?
>>
>>16444159
>stupidity is contagious
That's how Islam is transmitted between brown people.

File: Laugh.jpg (50 KB, 600x608)
50 KB
50 KB JPG
>The Islamic eschatological end of days starts when the Kaaba is destroyed.
>Qarmatian heretic sect destroyed the Kaaba in 929AD and it had to be rebuilt.
>Muslim excuse for it being ~1100 years later and the world not ending is literally "Uhh...It didn't count! But next time it theoretically happens it actually will!"
Sub 80 religion.
>>
>>16445829
>The Islamic eschatological end of days starts when the Kaaba is destroyed
source?
>>
>sub 80 anon thinks it was destroyed
ironic
>>
I thought the Qarmatian raid was evidence to debunk some dumb-shit that Angels protect the Kaaba and would kill anyone who fucked with it?
I never heard it being used in a eschatological argument.
>>
>>16445847
>Angels protect the Kaaba and would kill anyone who fucked with it?
source?

File: Dostoevsky.jpg (854 KB, 1079x1340)
854 KB
854 KB JPG
Who is your hero/role-model?
12 replies and 4 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>16443685
Cincinnatus and George Washington. I admire any man willing to give up power once their job is done.
>>
>>16444148
Washington had more power as a businessman than he would have had as a king. Kings draw a lot of attention from the public. Businessmen are free to accumulate power behind the scenes.
>>
File: Vasari-Lorenzo.jpg (129 KB, 807x1006)
129 KB
129 KB JPG
Sertorius for fighting against the eternal optimate and Lorenzo de Medici for being a chill nigga funding reinasance projects and keeping the peace in Italy
>>
>>16443685
Hitler. He went from homeless to supreme leader of a nation he wasn’t born in.
>>
>>16443685
Zhou Enlai

File: nigger.png (650 KB, 853x1374)
650 KB
650 KB PNG
He did it didn't he?
3 replies and 1 image omitted. Click here to view.
>>
He might have been the wrong negro, they were too hasty.
>>
>>16444162
He was probably guilty. Most victims of lynchings were guilty of we're to be honest. I mean think about it, if whites wanted to genocide blacks then they would have done so already. They only really killed criminal negroes.
>>
>>16444650
>Man Southerners are psychotic
Hookworms don't play around.
>>
>>16444162
buck got cake
>>
>>16444650
I don't understand. Don't leftists want to abolish the police and have community law enforcement?

Hey muslims, why are you so committed to the idea that muhammad was the final prophet? How do you know that he wasn't one of the false prophets that Jesus spoke about? Jesus said "you will know them by their fruits". And from I can tell, muhammad was a dick-head.
12 replies omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>16445640
God gave humanity the ability to tell good from evil, beheading boys of age 14 because they were forced by their elders to take up arms to defend their homes is evil, a prophet would not do evil, therefore Mohammad was not a prophet and Islam is dismissed.
>>
>>16445645
>Hurr Durr I'm a retarded retard and I speak for retards across the world, Jesus told me my retardendess makes me special
>>
File: images (2) (20).jpg (42 KB, 783x391)
42 KB
42 KB JPG
>>16444335
>Hey muslims, why are you so committed to the idea that muhammad was the final prophet?
Yes I have an explaination, he was the last one that will found a "New" religion, new cults will sprout naturally, ususually folded into a major religion, because now it is solely into Hard STEM.
>How do you know that he wasn't one of the false prophets...
1 Peter 4:5
"But remember that they will have to face God, who stands ready to judge everyone, both the living and the dead."

All of my thesis in all my fields was to reverse engineer what happened to my body and how it came to be, and many Many more things.

Or in otherwords, and full fledged PhD for the Prophethood, documented to the anatomical, sometimes genetics, sometimes this is that....

Hard to count to ininity in digit at a time (normal learning), Ive had a lot of artificial help, though much I WAY out did some things hardcore.......I literally suffer for it physically to this day.

Because from MY perspective, MY religion is older than ALL of them. My Prophet "year" is somewhere near 40k, (I think when I did it it was 36/37 or something I wasnt trying to be super precise but median.
>>
>>16445730
>MY
Which the whole "hold my religion over you" thing very offensive, its usually just cultal and easy of us, for brevity "Christian", too me a long time to not have an issue with that because the Spirit called me Jesus but I can see a clear different on a fundemental level (combat veteran), not looks like it was my childhood friend blood line, some sort of moon, alter ego, its the expressive art side of me that isnt hardcore Pure Mathematics, but there are many division of humanity onamy lines for many reasons.

Dimensional Analysis, Number Theory (but Number Theory is dead for printed stuff, all super outdated weak, introductory at best, Norman, some others Im sure online or on campus maybe, its a small field but Rarely used to its full potential.

Its doesnt feel good, think of all of that as angels, gods are "angels", its segmented of the whole, its Mono for a reason. Savants show up and live amongst the people and their BiogmMagnetic signal effects the world, hierarchically.

As you saw in Israel, it is a peculiar situation. Why they acted they way they do, or that Muslims control the Rock, they organized.

Not Muslims, Mohammadin, like Christians, because Gene expression is what youre mirroring.

Learn from it at your side as a tool, not some master slave or nanny comfort brodad or something, all of that just personifies your psychological issues back at you.
>>
>>16444335
Moon flesh worship (islam) is the religion created for brown people in places with no children of God. It is probably responsible for why brown people are obsessed with white women because it implants their minds with racial inferiority complex.

File: frog3.png (195 KB, 500x500)
195 KB
195 KB PNG
What were the Genesis editors thinking when they put two contradictory creation stories right next to each other?
75 replies omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>16444216
Do you know the word "gullible" in hebrew?
>>
>>16440864
No, because in Genesis 1 God creates Adam last. It just appears the other way around to Adam, who's unique perspective from within creation and time is the topic of Genesis 2.

You'll note that in Genesis 1, God creates men and women at the same time. Whereas in Genesis 2, Adam is created before Eve.

That's because God sees all events has happening simultaneously, whereas man perceives events in linear time and in a way that is subjective and self centered.

Adam's perspective is the same as ours, we are all the center of our own personal worlds. But to God we aren't really the center, he sees things objectively.

You shouldn't read Genesis 1 as if it were happening in time, you should see the 7 iterations of creation not as literal days but more like an order of operations.

Even though a mathematical algorithm appears to us to work itself out over time, ideally the steps involved take place simultaneously.

Genesis 2 meanwhile takes the single verse of the creation of man in Genesis 1, and draws it out into a chronological sequence.
>>
>>16444194
I can do you one better
https://mechon-mamre.org/p/pt/pt0.htm

side-by-side english and hebrew
>>
There's absolutely no reason to assume the contradiction is a result of editing.

In fact, much the opposite. Malicious editors don't like contradictions, they would have made the account more consistent not less.

It's not as if they didn't notice, editors are paid to notice these things. Especially when the event is critically important to their religion, and the difference is on the very next page.

No, the proximity and relation of this contradiction actually suggests the difference is entirely intentional.

It's supposed to subtly illustrate the difference between man and God. That's what the whole book is about, it would make sense for a microcosm of that theme to be present in the beginning.

Most people the first time they read the book don't even notice this. That's part of the point. When a student has learned enough about scripture to actually notice this and ask about it, his master knows he's ready to receive this teaching concerning his own perspective. That's how you're supposed to learn scripture, someone explains it's deeper meaning to you when you're ready for it. Not before.
>>
>>16445810
>In fact, much the opposite. Malicious editors don't like contradictions, they would have made the account more consistent not less.
You don't understand the Documentary Hypothesis. The editor isn't "malicious", he's taking multiple sources and combining them into one account. The amount of editing is purposefully kept to a minimum because the editor wanted to preserve the differences between the sources.

It's the same as the different accounts of Saul's death. The author of Samuel did not intend for these two accounts to be reconciled. They're two accounts of Saul's death that differ, and he chose to leave them side-by-side for us to interpret.

There is no issue here except if you're coming at it with the assumption that every sentence of the Bible is literal, 100% factual truth, rather than religious/political texts written by Judahite scribes who had their own written sources that they utilized. Some of these sources are even cited despite being lost to history, such as the annals used in Kings, or the Book of Jasher.

Russians are way more intelligent at war than Germans.
>prove me wrong
37 replies and 3 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>16441969
Russian population through most of its history was way smaller than of russia from the 18th and 20th century
>>
>>16445042
shut the fuck up russiaboo, talking about 100 years ago as if people should take dying in droves as an example. WW1 is seen as a horrendous tragedy for russia its just another war. FUCK THAT
>>
>>16445310
Same could be said about literally any country you useless nigger
>>
>>16445317
Assuming you are that anon, then you're the one who started talking about fucking Napoleon, which is an additional 100 years further back in history.

And if you arent that anon, then shut the fuck up. I'm not a tankie, I'm simply calling out the stupidity most anons have cause they keep parroting old ww2 myth about "human wave tactic". You havent read a single book on the eastern front and wouldnt fucking know two things about how the Russians were actually able to defeat the wehrmacht.
>>
>>16441680
Thing is "Russia" is a made up construct and you can easily refer to most Russian "citizens" by their "original" ethnicity.

Considering wars happen in the border regions, they involve even less people from the core areas. Russian wars have mostly been fought by whatever people live in those border regions and also, through experience in being involved in an actual war, have gained in military ranks and so, most "Russians" who make it to top brass, have been from those people and thus, non "Russians"

File: 1705209020117914.png (1.16 MB, 904x1701)
1.16 MB
1.16 MB PNG
Reminder the therm "white" is a de facto jewish invention. Only zog cattle use it

N obody in germany, Poland, France etc was calling himself white pre 2010. The only people who do it unironically are leftists.
Why?
Because everybody else was using europeans.

Isnt it funny that the same person who said white labeled nealry every other ethnicity based upon the continent they come from?
Asian Americans.
Indian Americans
African Americans
Whites

Do you know why?
Because it detaches the home continent of europeans from europe. White is something blatant, something without a home, something that doesnt belong anywhere.
If i say im european i attach myself to a continent, a place every "white" person originates from.

Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
59 replies and 19 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
File: 20240328_215447.jpg (87 KB, 607x445)
87 KB
87 KB JPG
>>16445356
Like this?
>>
>>16445380
With the current date
>>
>>16445280
I dunno, I feel like I have more in common with the Chinese-American guy who lives down the block from me and watches the same TV shows and reads the same books than my third cousin who herds sheep in Ireland.
>>
>>16445510
Both far-western and far-eastern Eurasian races civilized, everything in-between is mentally ill barbarians.
>>
>>16443713
The other way around. Beards make men look more homogeneous. Shave the beard they look more distinct.

File: ah.jpg (133 KB, 1200x900)
133 KB
133 KB JPG
>Explains how marxists like you aren't interested in solving economic issues
>Explains how inflation has been rising since jews started to charge interest on money after aryans gave them refuge and that inflation was previously low in comparison
>Explains how jewish central banks have lead to more wars and revolutions.
>Explains how germans have been unjustly discriminated against
>Explains how jewish behavior both now and in the past have kept non-jews down and how expelling jews is sometimes the only way for a nation to prosper
>Explains how class war has been constructed to deliberately to hurt workers
>Explains why the fact that every nation hates jews isn't sufficient evidence to suggest that jews are always victims
>Everything said by him is backed up by extensive research
>Gives concrete solutions on how to fix these issues


Where is YOUR evidence to back up your ridiculous claims about the racist evil nazis? By all means, look into national socialism, i promise you that you can't debunk it.

>inb4 i get told to shut the fuck up by someone who hasn't researched natsoc and is triggered by these FACTS
>inb4 someone says punching nazis is good

Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>
>>16444605
>and discuss it WITH SOURCES
You first. So far you haven't quoted a single source.
>>
File: 1629653686748.png (319 KB, 1080x315)
319 KB
319 KB PNG
>>16444605
>did hitler...
don't care what a homeless meth addicted artfaggot who had no kids say anything
>>
>>16444639
He wasn't methaddicted
>>
File: so then I said.jpg (423 KB, 720x906)
423 KB
423 KB JPG
>>
I haven't researched Nazism and you should shut the fuck up
Punching Nazis is good
Dresden should be bombed again
According to my anecdotal evidence Hitler once let a member of the Jewish Elite go
Said anecdotal evidence was found by historian Shlomo Goldstein
Bigot
Go back to /pol/
Slide thread
Sage

ALLAH split the moon or Muhammad split the moon?
33 replies and 4 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>16445638
My name's not Mohammed and I don't wear a Hijab, thanks but no thanks
>>
>>16442832
I dont idea, but It seems strange to me that other cultures with close time zones like India or Europe haven't recorded something as crazy as the moon splitting in half.
>>
>>16444260
>Anyone could pull a hadith chain out of their
The hadith scholars didn't just accept hadith from anyone. Bukhari was a known student of Ishaq and Ahmad who were students of Al-Shafi'i, who was the student of Malik who learned from Al-Zuhri who learned from Sa'id ibn Musayyib who learned from Abu Hurayra. If someone were to forge a chain, for example from Ahmad, the students of Ahmad would immediately say, "we don't know you, we never heard this hadith before etc."

There were many documented cases of people like this and were caught by hadith scholars, who claimed to hear from some scholar yet were solitary in their report. Some of them add unto famous hadith, additions that aren't corroborated by other narrations. This level of verification isn't found in textual criticism.

>my comment about your terrible standards in using liberal critical scholarship
There's nothing liberal about critical scholarship. Textual criticism is highly uncertain, but we can say with certainty that the gospels were in fact tampered with by scribes without regard for preserving the original. This is known through textual variants which are charged with significant theological motives. Examples: Johannine Comma, only begotten god vs son, Pericope Adulterae

The Qur'anic textual variants, however, are so miniscule and insignificant in comparison. The Sana'a lower text only differs in wording, example: "he said, Lord" vs "and he said, my Lord" or "Lord in my prayers" vs "in my prayers Lord". The general agreement of textual critics is that much of the Sana'a variants come from scribal error, and there is a lot of evidence for this.

Christians like to pretend that textual criticism is both a problem for Muslims and Christians alike, but really it is just a problem for Christians, who relied on papyrus manuscripts for transmission.
>>
>>16445751
>haven't recorded something as crazy as the moon splitting in half
If it happened for only a short while like 1-5 minutes, most people wouldn't have noticed. And if they did, it can't be taken for granted that those who noticed would write about it and their writing survived for so long. It's completely plausible these records were lost to time.
>>
>>16445751
>other cultures with close time zones like India or Europe haven't recorded something as crazy as the moon splitting in half.
The thought didn't cross hour mind that God made it an event within an instance? Like it was only visible to persons on a specific server, in this case Arabs occupying a particular space and time


[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10]
[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10]
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.