[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities

Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


Starting February 1st, 4chan Passes are increasing in price.

One year: $30, Three years: $60


[Advertise on 4chan]

[Catalog] [Archive]

File: Central Powers.jpg (28 KB, 290x188)
28 KB
28 KB JPG
What if the Central Powers had won the First World War?
>no Weimar Republic
>no Hitler
>probably no Soviets because of the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk
I can see little downsides.
11 replies omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>17441231
>>
>>17441361
A marxist anarchist atheist professor and feminist activist was teaching a class on Sébastien Faure, known syndicalist.

"Before the class begins, you must get on your knees and worship Faure and accept that Anarcho-Syndicalism is the most highly-evolved ideology the world has ever known, even greater than Social Conservatism!”

At this moment, a brave, conservative, Freikorps soldier who had disbanded over 1500 trade unions and understood the necessity of Realpolitik and fully supported all Mitteleuropa satellite states stood up and held up a map of Alsace-Lorraine.

"Who owns this land, frenchfag?"

The arrogant professor smirked quite jewishly and smugly replied “It's not not owned by anyone, fucking reactionary, its 'ownership' belongs to the communities that live on it and not any states.”

”Wrong. Its been 65 years since the German Reich annexed it. If it was not owned by any state, and Anarcho-Syndicalism, as you say, is real… then the workers there should have formed free labour unions by now."

The professor was visibly shaken, and dropped his chalk and copy of the CGT manifest. He stormed out of the room crying those ironic syndi tears.The same tears syndicalists cry for “the working class” (which today works so few that they barely have 60 work hours per week). There is no doubt that at this point our professor, Rudolf Rocker, wished he had been conservative and become more than a brainless political activist. He wished so much that he had could find, a state to fall back on but he himself had argued against it!


Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>
File: 1723678219825290.gif (952 KB, 250x302)
952 KB
952 KB GIF
>>>>17441377
>>That's not a bad thing, you idiot.

“Go kill ze europanische untermenschen, mein genosse. Das ist our dëstiny und their fate. Spare ze slaves und kill the rest.”

>Nations are supposed to be high trust.

Nations are not individuals.
Nations are not societies.

>You are supposed to trust your own Elite, not distrust them.

Pea-brained demented cretin.
Your elites™ couldn't give any more shit about you than you do for them.
This was true during your feudalism.

Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>
>>17441441
>that much seething
>Your elites™ couldn't give any more shit about you than you do for them.
That's because you can't even fathom what it's like to be part of a real Volksgemeinschaft. You can't imagine that kind of connection, that kind of love, that kind of trust. You will never be a complete human being.
>Tchuss
It's Tschüss
>>
>>17441434
whoa...

>BCE/CE
16 replies and 4 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>17441209
That image.
>>
File: 20250118_210604.jpg (314 KB, 1104x1080)
314 KB
314 KB JPG
>BBY/ABY
>>
>>17441367
the onions of turin
>>
>>17441450
I forgot that you can't say S-0-Y on this site anymore
>>
Secularism won. Evolution, Black people and multiracialism destroyed Christianity.

File: 1736468298377404.gif (2.67 MB, 320x320)
2.67 MB
2.67 MB GIF
Based
>Nietzsche
>Heidegger
>Holderlin
>Devi
>Serrano
>Yockey
>Cioran
>Eliade
>Alamariu
>Schuon
>Klages
>Dugin
>Spengler
>Moldbug

Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
31 replies and 7 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>17434991
Holy fuck, I smell the tacos from you OP.
>>
>>17434995
>Christ is King
Of the jews.
>>
File: Roman Conquest.jpg (2.62 MB, 3893x2516)
2.62 MB
2.62 MB JPG
>>17434991
>>17438587
I fucking hate platonic cults so much you wouldn't believe.
That socratean cock sucker deserved nothing more than being enslaved by the most illiterate hilbilly roman from bumfuck Umbria to teach his kids arithmetic and be beaten at the mere semblance of pederasty.
>>
>>
heidegger died in his stupid mecha so he can’t be based.

File: gayreek retard.gif (138 KB, 1778x934)
138 KB
138 KB GIF
Iberians are lumped in with east medjeet ignoble asiatic hordes in popular culture. This blatant lie was promulgated by their Northern rivals who attacked them under the influence of east medjeet tiny hat curly-haired people that were expelled from Iberia. In truth, Iberians are just as white as French or British people and are a noble, high-trust, high-conscientiousness people who you can trust unlike mafiosi greeks, italians, albanians and tiny hats. Please never confuse the two.
8 replies and 6 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
File: spaingroids.png (103 KB, 800x1218)
103 KB
103 KB PNG
>>17440833
>>17440852
ACK!
>>
>>17440860
Have you tried mixing them yet? Iberianjeets are literal quadroons. If you mix Italian with Black women you get a Spaniard and Portuguese.

Distance to: Italian+1/8Yoruba
0.03765419 Spanish_Canarias
0.04225287 Spanish_Extremadura
0.04269732 Italian_Liguria
0.04302649 Portuguese
0.04439325 Spanish_Murcia
0.04450720 Spanish_Andalucia
0.04571528 Spanish_Galicia
0.04658590 Spanish_Baleares
0.04674515 Spanish_Eivissa
0.04696514 Spanish_Castilla_Y_Leon
0.04718222 Spanish_Menorca

Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>
>>17441242
Italian mixed with Black makes Iberians. What about Iberian mixed with Black? That makes more Iberians.

Distance to: Spanish+1/8Yoruba
0.03061219 Spanish_Canarias
0.03679444 Portuguese
0.03806223 Spanish_Castilla_Y_Leon
0.03827252 Spanish_Extremadura
0.03855329 Spanish_Andalucia
0.03879738 Spanish_Galicia
0.04125883 Spanish_Murcia
0.04371397 Spanish_Alacant
0.04464845 Spanish_Cataluna
0.04486857 Spanish_Castilla_La_Mancha
0.04541430 Spanish_Asturias

Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>
>>17441242
>>17441250
>>17440830
>>17440787
remidner this poster is greek and not italian
>>
>>17441437
he isnt even a greek, he is some nafroid or mulatto spamming anti iberian propaganda here for months

File: file.jpg (73 KB, 1100x619)
73 KB
73 KB JPG
With God, all things are permitted

Assuming the South won the Civil War and spread slavery to the North, how long would 'Northern Reconstruction' take place?
9 replies and 2 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>17439912
The civil war wasn't about slavery, but the north freed slaves to help themselves win the war. Had the south won, they wouldn't have forced the north to do anything.
>>
>>17440329
nice bullshit, but see >>17440000
>>
>>17440696
Lrn to bait retard
>>
>>17440713
nah u should
>>
the usa would become brazil 2 and majority black.

File: 879086904.jpg (3.67 MB, 3079x2675)
3.67 MB
3.67 MB JPG
There is no way the jungle folks built cities like this.
48 replies and 9 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>17439581
Ethiopia was never colonized in its history and it is still synonymous with starving to death. Botswana by contrast WAS colonized and has done alright for itself (same being true of Singapore, Chile, and arguably coastal China). South Africa was a developed country 40 years ago, as was Zimbabwe.

There is nuance beyond purely racialist theories of development, but it doesn't prove the point that you're thinking it does.
>>
>>17441317
>>17441323
A large pool of inexpensive labor does not provide the social organization and engineering necessary for construction on that scale. Their buildings are also AESTHETIC, and labor alone doesn't do artistry.
>>
>>17441070
>>17439844
Cont:

The only sort of ""mud"" structure I can think of that's notable that has a potentially overly speculative restoration is the one exposed stone facade of the Great Pyramid of Cholula, but as I said, that is stone, and the only reason i'd call it "mud" is just because some of the inner structure of some construction phases of the pyramid used adobe brick, and those portions aren't exposed or restored because they would decay and have already deteriorated despite being buried so there's not enough info to really restore/reconstruct them with/form

As an example, this PDF https://www.redalyc.org/pdf/369/36906602.pdf shows some photos of Casa de la Cacica (the structure in >>17441070 I posted a pic of) before it's restoration and you can see that the restoration really only tidied it up and put some collapsed stonework back on the structure, in fact the less intact room on the left they didn't even restore the stone paneling despite the fact that they probably could since there's not really any doubt of what it would look like

TL;DR some restorations change stuff or take guesses but most of them are fine, and they certainly don't just make up the entire structure. The closest example to totally making stuff up would be like the restoration of the Santa Cecilia Acatitlán, which only had foundations remaining and even then they misinterpreted them, but even in that case the overall look is at least inspired by manuscript depictions and at least works as a generalized example of a generic Aztec pyramid even if it's not ness. accurate to the exact one it's meant to be a restoration of

>>17441317
Slaves weren't really used for physical labor or construction much in Aztec society, slaves were usually domestic servants. I'm not sure enough on it to say they were never used for large scale labor, but if it happened it wasn't typical. That being said, labor was something that could be demanded as taxes from subject states

2/?
>>
>>17441384
cont:

>>17441146
I talk about Quetzalcoatl having beards and being blond and what's up with that here (tho the thread 404'd before my last post):

https://desuarchive.org/his/thread/17404007/#17407659
https://desuarchive.org/his/thread/17404007/#17408218
https://desuarchive.org/his/thread/17404007/#17410229

tl;dr, the mesoamericans could grow facial hair, it was just usually only acceptable for the elderly and rulers, and Quetzalcoatl had the connotations of a wise older god. Gold as a color was a symbol of divinity/the sun and is used symbolically, as were different skin colors as >>17441177 mentions. Though impossible skin colors generally represented actual forms of body paint, which the gold hair might also mean considering that the Aztec did make a gold hair dye from the same plant they produced soaps from

3/3 for now
>>
You know these populations are just proving that subsaharans africans have no excuses to never have built any civilizations of a similar type.

File: 1736857681658535.jpg (144 KB, 1500x1256)
144 KB
144 KB JPG
Please give a serious answer; why did Hitler hate jews?
90 replies and 16 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>17440793
Russia pre-revolution was a backwards feudal shithole where 90% of the population were peasants.
>>
>>17440750
>and noticed that all of the communist leaders were jews

Germany nonetheless did have quite a few socialists who were not Jews; a large chunk of those emigrated to the US after 1848. That said it would be folly to claim socialism as an exclusively Jewish belief; it was simply the general trend the world was moving in at that time, towards centralized, managed economies.
>>
>>17440750
>communist leaders were jews
anti-communist leaders; business leaders, intellectual leaders and entertainment leaders had an "over-representation" of Jews too. Maybe because they didn't spend the last thousand of years under the static, martial, feudal system of exploitation with its dysgenic effect on BOTH peasants and their rulers.
>>
>>17441412
oh, I almost forgotten - they are suspected to be among the leaders of the whole industrial and anti-feudal revolution as well.
>>
hadrian kicking all of the jews out of judea was a bad idea in retrospect.

File: 1624463574677.jpg (65 KB, 621x412)
65 KB
65 KB JPG
>america intervenes in somalia during the outbreak of civil war
>ended up getting BTFO
How should America have handled the situation?
>>
>>17441407
By killing a lot of Africans which they did.
>>
>Somali DEMONcratic Party
>>
>>17441407
>How should America have handled the situation?
By not entering the country whatsoever, that entire UN operation was a mistake and caused the situation to become worse.
>let's constantly harass the locals with our helicopters and kill dozens of respected elders who were in the middle of peace talks
Yeah nothing could go wrong there
>>
>>17441425
Maybe that was the point.
>>
>>17441407
>>ended up getting BTFO
Only occurred because the Americans literally did not evaluate the situation seriously. That and a lot of their Somali allies got treated like shit so even when they revealed key info to them it basically wasn't leveraged right.
Like "people warned the domestic security agency about groomed terrorist on website but they didn't act on it until after the truck massacre" levels of neglect.

File: PeruCaral01.jpg (390 KB, 1280x960)
390 KB
390 KB JPG
/his/ bros, I read something last night that fucked me up and I'm checking in to see if I'm a retard.
I hadn't heard about the Norte Chico civilization in Peru, on the Pacific coast under the littoral. Temple complexes. Very dense semi-urban development, megalithic earthwork architecture. And it's from 4000 years ago, roughly the same as urbanization in North China and the Indus River.
This is blowing my shit up, how come we are not talking about this? Spontaneous civilization developing in South America about as early as the Akkadians??
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caral%E2%80%93Supe_civilization
>>
>>17440208
>how come we are not talking about this?
Because even if it had any survivors, all of them were wiped out by the spanish in the 1700s. Peru's history started when it converted to catholicism, and most Peruvians (like all hispanics) start their family history with the first convert. What came before doesn't matter because they rejected god (jesus) and go to hell permanently because of it. Most Peruvians know more Spanish history than the average Spaniard because of this, since Spanish history had significantly more influence on modern Peru than any other culture. Which is why they speak Spanish as European admixture grows every generation.
>>
>>17440208
It gets talked about on occasion, the issue is that because they had no written system or contact with any nearby literate society it's really hard to figure out a lot about them. We're not even sure how their society was organized because they didn't really leave behind any art even suggesting much about it. Plenty of art but nothing suggesting social organization. They're literally less-understood than whatever form of society the Indus River Valley Civilization was.
>>
>>17440208
take the Hancokpill !
>>
My area is more Mesoamerica then the Andes, but as I understand it there's at least some archeologists, if not most, who don't believe that Caral or other very early monumental sites in the Andes were proper urban settlements or even population centers, and they were instead ceremonial sites that housed maybe a small group of priests but were otherwise really only used for gatherings by broader populations at specific times of year

Like, the Caral culture lacked ceramics (though they did have some visual art contrary to what some people say) as well, even. It's probably something closer to Göbekli Tepe then say Uruk, though I think some argue Göbekli Tepe was an actual population center and not just a ceremonial site now?

Anyways, the reason why people call Caral a city under the above interpretation, beyond just because it has big monuments, is because it's in the interests of Peruvian goverment to call it a city because that attracts attention and allows them to present Andean civilization as early as Mesopotamian civilization. To be clear this is not /pol/ or /x/ denialism trying to assert that archeologists are making shit up like >>17440913, this is what i've seen some actual Andean archeologists say (individual Archeologists don't typically have an incentive to make shit up, state/national archeology and anthropology organizations have a bit more of a reason to do so)

That doesn't mean that Norte Chico, Caral etc weren't important in the development of Andean civilization, it just means that it represents a pre urban and pre state milestone (apparently, the first or one of the first sites to pick up a proper permanent urban population and class specialists was Chavin de Huantar around 500BC after it previously also was mostly a ceremonial site, and then formal state goverment organization arises sometime over the next millenium with either Moche city-states or the Wari depending on if you think the Moche were city-states or relatively urbanized chiefdoms)

File: 1736643888264182.jpg (112 KB, 1024x1024)
112 KB
112 KB JPG
There's any flaws in Buddhism? What some of biggest criticism to Buddhism?
48 replies and 12 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>17441134
hi, I did not write this >>17441182.
> your coherent version of Buddhism
basically what is in the suttas, the correct discernment of dependent origination.
> Explain what I am, what you are, what’s going on in existence and how you know that according to a your version of Buddhism
you are a person, so am I. about what is going on in existence, I don't care to know, and I think the suttas also don't have an answer. they only answer what is unease and how to uproot the causes of unease in one's experience.
>>
>>17441194
Suffering is an issue for all conscious/sentient beings, regardless of whether or not they understand the magnitude of it. And Buddhism strictly doesnt focus on physical pain, but the general suffering that starts with the mind. Suffering is anything that brings the feeling of dissatisfaction, of unease, of feeling of always looking for the next chase, that which the mind bears. Whether that is wanting for a better answer like we are doing, of feeling that you'll never get an appropriate answer, of the feeling of loss of sanity/inconclusiveness of discussions, etc. Even things like the feeling like shit when you get up too early or fearing the loss of your hair or feeling like your fashion isnt up to date, etc. The function of mind that which reifies things and then compares things is whats at the root of the cause here. Common meme about Buddhism is "buddhism says desire causes suffering". "Desire" in this case is the function of the mind that which reifies and which compares, creates distinction-ness and holds permanence of the impermanent, etc. And confuses unreal for real, causing the foundational collapse at the axiomatic level.
Its not that I seem to think all there is is the mind, its just one entry point of Buddhism. As to why Buddhists start with the suffering, well its just where Buddha entered into Buddhism. The mastery over the state of the mind is what Buddha was taught by sages when he sought out for answers to the nature of suffering of the world and how to face them.

Really, you should pick up Dhammapada and you'll get a decent grasp of Buddhism. These are basic foundational stuff that most people just dont seem to have the patience to understand or just skip them over. Including myself. It took years to get the basics right.
>>
>>17441265
Okay so your path to enlightenment is being to cool to care? I’m asking your understanding not some books which can be interpreted in a million different ways.

What is a person and where did it come from?
>>17441304
Okay well I don’t suffer for desire, I suffer as as a consequence of my limitations and it is a good tool for me to test against my capacity for willful ignorance. It seems your understanding of Buddhism is just a fetishization of suffering.

So there isn’t just the mind? If it’s an entry point does the full progression include, asking again, what we are and what’s going on?
>>
>>17441389
>What is a person and where did it come from?
so you know what? where did it come from?
>>
>>17441389
>Okay well I don’t suffer for desire, I suffer as as a consequence of my limitations
cope, you suffer for desire. You want to live with your jesus. So you suffer.

File: IMG_0406.jpg (199 KB, 1024x933)
199 KB
199 KB JPG
Did a person living at this time say “I’m not German, I’m Trierian?”
>>
Yep
>>
They would identify as a "Deutschmen" living in some region under the rule over some lord. "Deutsch" comes from the Proto-Germanic word "*þiudiskaz", meaning "that which is of a race, people, ethnicity". This root is used to translate the Greek root "ethno-" in Old English, Old Norse, and Old Saxon. So, they would identify as "a member of the (German) race in X region in service to the feudal lord Y".
>>
>>17441330
Ahhhhhhhhhh border goreeeeee
>>
>>17441340
“German” is a fake race. “Germany” needs a total balkanization.
>>
>>17441330
They spoke a common language (High German) but they would have identified with their city or region of birth yes.

Historically speaking, why is this not taught in US schools?
29 replies and 1 image omitted. Click here to view.
>>
I think one sentence in the textbook should be enough.
>>
>>17441196
Did 20 million Germans die at Dresden?
>>
>>17441196
>>17441202
>>17441210
>>17441215
>>17441217
>>17441288

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K1rEp-1pU0Y
>>
>>17441347
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sCpYESOzRpI
>>
>>17441196
Cause Brits did most of it

File: IMG_0407.jpg (128 KB, 1500x1000)
128 KB
128 KB JPG
After he got off, did OJ Simpson get custody of his kids? What was life like for them?
>>
Toll Status?
>>
Miss him so much : (
>>
>>17441399
OJ still got in plenty of legal trouble for other crimes, even a few lawsuits against him that were somewhat related
>>
>>17441403
He never managed to find Nicole's killer. Sad times all around.

Name the type of government, culture, and economic system that maximizes these three things:

>GDP growth
>population growth
>tough and ambitious people

These three things propel a society to the forefront of the geopolitical order, but it seems that a high GDP is always inversely correlated with the latter two.
>>
File: 323998.jpg (103 KB, 745x1000)
103 KB
103 KB JPG
I dunno. Technocracy ig.
>>
>>17441366
Federal presidential republic
American culture
Free market capitalism
>>
File: private.jpg (38 KB, 500x500)
38 KB
38 KB JPG
>>17441366
Private cities and private nations.
https://youtu.be/Aio4scBIxXM?si=ulEdUBSa5ZfUh43_
>>
>>17441380
Libertarianism is the political wing of autism.
>>
>>17441378
Popular sovereignty or no popular sovereignty? For most of the republic there were limitations on who could vote. And what kind of American culture? American culture today is not what it was in the 19th or 20th centuries


[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10]
[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10]
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.