Why did Arabic succeed in Egypt and Andalus but fail to take over Iran?Why did Latin take over France but not Britain?Why did Germanic take over Britain and southern Germany but not Northern France?Why die Hungarian succeed despite the demographic imbalance but Bulgar failed?
>>18348040This is propaganda>>18348037There was no Semitic presence in 700 CE Iberia
>>18344644>They survived Hellenization thoughGreek rule over Egypt was explicitly a caste system where only the most elite of native Egyptian society was allowed in to the same circles as Greeks. Also they maintained their own elite under the Ptolemies who continued to use their own language without interruption. The same under the Romans, although their elite was thoroughly Romanised under them and became part of their system. Arabic rule crushed local elites, imported Arabic tribes to carve out the country as the new ruling local elite, the local language was completely expelled from the administration both local and for the state being replaced by Arabic. This is a process that came with conversion to Islam as well which greatly encouraged becoming Arab and speaking Arab. It took over 700 years until Egypt was majority Muslim and Arabic speaking.
>>18348037this
>>18348093>This is a process that came with conversion to Islam as well which greatly encouraged becoming Arab and speaking Arab. It took over 700 years until Egypt was majority Muslim and Arabic speaking.Wrong, Coptic was extinct by 1200 CE(either fully or very close to fully) and was likely majority muslim by around 1000-1100 CE>Greek rule over Egypt was explicitly a caste system where only the most elite of native Egyptian society was allowed in to the same circles as Greeks.But Arabs were segregated too and that seen as a reason why arabization worked.>Arabic rule crushed local elites, imported Arabic tribes to carve out the country as the new ruling local elite, the local language was completely expelled from the administration both local and for the state being replaced by Arabic.Is that really true?
>>18343325Iranians have always been elitists who think they're too good for the ME. They got surprise attacked by the region they least suspected of turning into a powerhouse, so they had the religion forced on them, but they refused everything else. I'd say they still cling to their irrelevant culture, but it looks like they desperately want to turn into Middle Eastern America.I remember going in an Iranian family's house for some work and finding The Bell Curve on their bookshelf. Wild people.
I have noticed that groups like Jews, Palestinians and Black Americans have this sense of entitlement. Haven't interacted much with either Jews or black Americans. When it comes to Palestinians they excepts you sympathies and support them 100%. They throw a tantrum if you don't and think your evil or something. Never meet any non-Palestinian Arab that likes them. They share the same sentiment that Palestinians are super entitled. Jordan and Lebanon took them in and supported them. But apparently that wasn't enough for them. They carved out their own state within these countries. Refuse to follow the laws of the lands they lived in and instead tried to force their host-country to live by their rules. They even tried to take control of these countries by starting civil wars. Forced fellow Arabs and Muslims to "donate" to their cause at gun point. All because woe is them, they were forced out of their homes during the Nakba. Do they think just because they were victims of the Jews, it means they are entitled "fight back" by any means, including at others expense?While also thinking everyone owes it to help them because they are victims. Do people become like this if you constantly tell them how they are victims and nothing was ever their fault? While I don't think the Nakba was nice, it doesn't mean the world owes them something.Do Jews and black Americans also think it's okay for them to leech and commit crimes because boohoo slavery and holocaust?
>>18344262I’m also native but non rez. It’s funny af how retarded and worshipful white liberals become around you when they find out about your native background. It’s why I never reveal it and hope people will think I’m a light skin Mexican instead.I could definitely take advantage of that shit and get ahead faster in life but I choose not to, not just out of morality but also because I don’t want to be put in a position that I’m not actually ready for or competent enough to be in. Also I don’t want to be seen as a victim because my tribe were based chads who BTFOed not only other tribes but also European powers.
>>18343294fpbp>haha, if I insult Jews and blacks they will never suspect I'm shilling for Israel
>>18347685>Guys let's just turn a blind eye over the shitty things the Palestinians have done in their struggle against Israel.Kuwait Arabs expelled Palestinians from their country for supporting the 1990 Iraqi invasion. You gonna blame Kuwait for being pro-Israel? There couldn't be any other obvious reasons why they were expelled?
>>18347136American blacks live infinitely better than 99% of the world, they're the least oppressed of the oppressed races by far, I can just go to any social media app right now and I will be met with an american black in less than 5 minutes and not even a black celebrity at that, other oppressed races could only dream of having this exposure
>>18344138Writing of a foid.
How was it possible?>Latin, introduce by the legions>it's a written language, there are schools, libraries to expand it and preserve it >language of the Church, administration, culture, etc. >barbarians that "want to be part of the Imperium" settled in the 'light green areas'>their languages have no alphabet, there are no schools >they adopt the religion and alphabet of the Romans >they refuse to adopt their language (Hungary literally had Latin as official language for 1 ENTIRE MILLENNIUM and nobody learned it)>Latin lost despite being superior and more beautifulHOW? It literally makes no sense!!Same for Turkey and Balkans, how Greek was replaced by Turkish and South Slavic languages if those were not only spoken by less people and had no alphabet, but also Greek was spoke in those regions for millennia and most people used it (and sounds better; jews translated the Torah to Greek because they admitted it was more beautiful than Hebrew)?!
>>18348057>Derivatives of Late Latin are spoken in literally all of these green areas. It didn't 'lose' at all. Those areas speak Germanic or Slavic languages, it was a total lose.>>18348057Why in 4 centuries, Latin did not penetrate in the lower classes of those areas?
>>18348044Linguistic proximity matters. Except Britain, Roman areas that adopted Latin originally spoke a Celtic language like Gaulish, Lepontic or Celtiberian, and Celtic languages are closely related to Italic languages like Latin. For Romania it's speculation but what probably happened is that a Latin-speaking population simply replaced the native population
>>18348162>Those areas speak Germanic or Slavic languages, it was a total lose.All the green areas speak a Romance language nigga
>>18348252Which Romance language???
>>18348044
Does doing the same things that fascist do make one a fascist?Or is it the intent that counts?
Why is the history of this sea so obscure and unheralded compared to that of the nearby Black or Mediterranean basins?
>>18347794Very kino map design made by god
>>18347977I would like to go Fishing in Baku
>>18347794Because Tartaria would have to be mentioned
>>18347794I always wondered why on older maps Caspian sea look different and of course, there is russian fringe theory for this
>>18347794>>18347977Would it be possible to establish a lucrative and successful career as a pirate in those waters?
Is this reality false and made by something that isn't God but thinks he is God? Can we come to know the Good? If we can know about God through the Bible, does that mean the Bible is more real than our own world? Or was the Bible written by an entity that is not God? If material reality is fake, then what are we? Souls floating in the aether flux?
>>18347708We are evil because, because a book says!
>>18348336Being weak is evil, and all evil comes from weakness.
Abrahagroids pretend a "religion" based on doing what feels spiritually intuitive, and jotting together a gospel from your gnosis is less intellectual than believing a fucking rando bookThe first is scientific thought, the second mindless cultist behaviour but somehow it's a conspiracy>>18348344So goodness is robbing and killing and raping because police will be after your ass, gotcha
>>18348348All of those crimes stem from some inherent weakness or limitation.
>>18348349No, you gotta be strong to face police and army, only the weak obey
KWAB
>>18339719Westerners always get raped by Slavic Bvlls
>>18345598They are sissies
>>18339719The British MI6 make up these stories to slander Russia
>>18339719Sexual reparations for Nazi atrocities, and it was a good thing
>>18339719Literally no actual evidence of this
Also no pedo accusation
>>18346520It should be noted that ALL the original stories of the Hitler's deviancy came from Eva Braun's sister. Supposedly Eva would gossip to her sister about the freaky things Hitler enjoyed.It's all third hand hearsay.
>>18346315The husband, the devoted father, the wine connoisseur, and three time ballroom dancing champion.
>>18346581That is a reliable source.
>>18346315>>18346493>>18346520>>18346613>>18346567>>18346563He was:>a vegan with constantly upset stomach, probably shit himself very often>had a Jewish doctor that gave him literal drugs, so he was high most of the time, like a hippie bitch>loved animals more than humans>drove his niece to suicide with his pedophilia and familyfucking>a literal ARTHOE>mentally unstable, histornic and easily depressedIf it was normal back then, he would become a tranny 100%.
>>18346315He was a British Rothschild who murdered 27 million citizens of Soviet Russia
Southern europeans must understand that germanics are inherently our biological enemies. There's no possible friendship, let alone alliance with them, we are too radically different. Unfortunately most meds are navie and well intended and don't see how much germanics hate them and resent them. If you look into the germanic nationalist groups they are far more obsessed with meds (and occasionally with slavs, especially in germany) that they are with non europeans.>>>/pol/528519740
>>18346977Dubs of truthnuke
It's funny to me how Europeans can hate people who are so nearby not only genetically but physically. It would be like a guy from Wisconsin having a deathwish against someone from Missouri. That's the distances we're dealing with here.
shalom
>>18347361Wisconsin and Missouri were empty when Europeans were honing their martial skills against the neighboring tribe from two hills over. Also, the genetic distance between Whites from Wisconsin and Missouri is less than it is between many European peoples who live within javelin distance of each other.
TGD now
the British killed many Indians
>>18348276>The country collapsed into a african warload style failed state in record time.Not even remotely close. Now I know you're trolling. India has its issue but it's not to the level of Sudan.
>>18348278Well true, but its because indians dont have the masculinity to actually fight like a savage african. they scream "BLOODY BASTERD BITCH" and honor rape eachothers children but theres little full scale warfare going on. Their izzat scam warfare is just a cultural race to the bottom for them. They will be sucking dung out of cows asses till the sun burns out.
>>18348148That sounds highly trustworthy
>>18348148>>18348183>>18348254>>18348263>>18348266Took all their toilets too!!! Bharatians invented the toilets but jealous mleccha G*ras took them!!! #ShameOnTheBritishers
>>18348149>Never happened but it should have/thread
“Pagans” never actually called themselves that. It was originally an insult that Christian writers used for anyone who didn’t follow Christianity or Judaism. It comes from the Latin word paganus meaning “rural” or “country-dweller” because even after Christianity became the state religion of the Roman Empire, rural areas still remained mostly pagan. Much of rural Italy, France, and Spain remained pagan well into the early Middle Ages. The Mani Peninsula in Greece remained pagan until at least the 8th century. Even Lithuanian paganism survived the Christianization of Lithuania in the 14th century in rural areas and the last actual Lithuanian pagan, Balčiūnas Minvydas-Vincas, died in 1908.“Pagan” wasn’t even the only term used by Christians for followers of pre-Christian polytheistic religions. In the Greek-speaking Byzantine Empire, they used the old ethnonym Hellene to refer to followers of Greek paganism (remember that they identified as Romans at this point, they didn’t use the term Hellene to refer to themselves again until the Greek War of Independence). In Germanic-speaking countries, they referred to followers of Germanic paganism as heathens which effectively had the same meaning as the Latin paganus, “rural” or “country-dweller.” The oldest usage of the Germanic name actually comes from the missionary Ulfilas who translated the Bible to Gothic (an East Germanic language) in the 4th century. When translating Mark 7:26, he translated the Greek word Ἑλληνίς (Hellēnis) meaning “Greek woman” to 𐌷𐌰𐌹𐌸𐌽𐍉 (haiþnō) meaning “heatheness.”
>>18346949Modern pagans using it for themselves wouldn't be the first example of a group reappropriating for themselves a term that originated as an insult. Geuzen (in fact the Dutch call the concept a Geuzennaam), Yankee, Marxist, Suffragette, Whig, Tory, Pinoy, Mormon, Quaker, Shaker, Methodist...
>>18346949True and it's deeply ironic that Christians have been paganized by secular humanism which spreads from cities and elite institutions leaving Christians the backwards rural folk
>>18346949>paganus meaning “rural” or “country-dweller”Eh, that doesn't sound too offensive.>>18347271Lutheran too.
>>18346949Pagan = Gentile =goyim
>>18347124Demons are not real and never were, take your meds now.
Are we not supposed to be proud of ourselves? Are we not minorities in reality?
>>18347473copeyou act like you didn't steal math from arabs and gunpowder from chineseyou can't even invent 5g lol
>>18347785>you act like you didn't steal math from arabsNo we don’t. We call them Arabic numerals. They’re not even FROM Arabs they came from INDIA.>gunpowder The Chinese discovered blackpowder. They didn’t do nearly as much with it.
>>18347787And the chinese are doing more with your archaic inventions :)
>>18347791Maybe. Be they Chinese or Indian or otherwise. The author of the book cited in the OP even jokes about just that scenario.
White people are controversial.
This is an avid threads of etymologies and so-called "comparative mythology" here where two users compulsively post articles they find on the internet and vote on everything there without any critical analysis, and one of these threads was about the Roman word "mars" being cognate with the Vedic word "Maruts." Let me humiliate youIt is claimed that the theonym Mars may derive from an Indo-European root *Māwort- (cf. Sanskrit Marutas) and that the theonym Vulcan may derive from *Wĺ̥keh2nos, but this is pure rubbish. Why?The claim that "Mars" comes from *Māwort- is questionable because: - Mars was originally an agricultural god (not a war god) and his name likely came from the Etruscan "Maris". - "Marutas" (Sanskrit) refers to gods of the wind, and is not related to Mars. The *Māwort- hypothesis seems inconsistent with linguistic and historical factsThe same goes for that theory about Poseidon being a sea god. I already explained it and humiliated that pair of wimps
The sound changes that created "Mar-" aren't Venetic. So, there's no need to propose Mars < *mrh2ti- ('destroying'). Instead, IE *marhut- > *mahwrt- > Old Latin Māvort- ('Mars'), related to Kassite Maruttaš and Sanskrit Marút-as. The stem also explains variants like *Māvortikos > Mārcus and *Māmortikos > Māmercus.https://www.academia.edu/42168852/Mars_Veneticus_and_the_palma_rule_
>>18346256>>18346511Kek, this retard has been reading some schizo's blog from 2008
>>18348017That's an excellent survey of the evidence. I don't know if Prosper is right about everything, but if someone were to write a new paper on the topic, it's required reading.One thing I'm not sure about is if /P...w/ > /P...m/ is possible. Prosper argues against it for Mavor- > Māmart-. For example, prōvulgō > prōmulgō, but this word is certainly a later development.OP doesn't deserve a sincere response though. It's clearly a mentally ill person with a personal grudge. Just look at how he talks. He's going to "humiliate" someone for sharing things actual linguists were talking about such as connecting Mars and the Maruts.OP, when you're done reading ancient blogs, read what real linguists say and write your own paper arguing with *them* and not your imagined enemies on 4chan. Newsflash: they think Mars is Indo-European and their surveys of the evidence are much more systematic than you could ever hope to accomplish by the shallow motivation you get when you're angry at your computer screen because you forgot to take your meds.
OP literally made a thread because he was triggered by what John Clayton said in some presentations... and someone shared that on 4chan. Op, uh, have you thought about writing an angry email to Clayton? Invite him to a showdown at a historical linguistics conference. Maybe you can bait him into it by offering to humiliate him, lmao.I would ask if you feel humiliated yet, but you're obviously too dumb to be self-aware.
Someone arrest John Clayton.Doesn't he know he's causing meltdowns on 4chan and ruining lives???
>The East India Company was a company that involved the collaboration of American Freemasons and British Freemasons>The American freemasons controlled the slave trade and the cotton industry of the 13 colonies>The British freemasons controlled the opium industry in IndiaWas the American revolutionary war a meme or made up story?
>>18348224No, the war was a sectarian dispute. Britain wanted 2 things:1. To abolish slavery in the colonies2. To end westward expansion of the colonies (but still keep the colonies)...and surprise surprise, the white KKKolonists opposed both of these so strongly and with such racist fervor that they actually went to war with their imperial benefactors over it
>>18348264>Britain wanted 2 things:>1. To abolish slavery in the coloniesThey renamed slavery to "indentured servitude" and continued on with their slave trade by exporting Indians to Africa and the Caribbeans. Abolishing slavery was a meme.
How common is it for men to be attracted to underage girls?
>>18347812>Go look into the silhouette studyDo you have a link to the study?
>>18347831>Sexual arousal and arousability to pedophilic stimuli in a community sample of normal men, Gordon C, Nagayama Hall, Richard Hirschman, Lori L. Oliver.They surveyed and measured phisiological features and even then, 1/4 of the men self reported being attracted to the minors.>The hypothesis that arousal to pedophilic stimuli is a function of general sexual arousability factors was supported in that pedophilic and adult heterosexual arousal were positively correlated, particularly in the physiological data.Funny how the longhouse study was forced to make the conclusion "just because youre are attracted to young girls doesnt mean youre a pedophile" instead of recentering the term and letting off the gas on the whole "sleeping with a teen slut is the pinnacle of evil" psyop.
>>18347311Being attracted to kids is probably a rare medical condition, but being attracted to young (and possibly "underage") but otherwise fully physically grown women (with full tits etc. - already in their procreation age in short) is probably very common for old fags because as their libido diminish with age they likely need _extremely_ attractive women (aka young ones) to even be able for any sexual intercourse.
>>18347331based
Depends on what you mean by 'underage'. 16-17 is very different from 12 or lower.
